5 ms·
the laffer curve is an abstraction, a thought experiment with no axis labelling, and no understanding of whether the axes scales are linear or not. it is theref
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
the laffer curve is an abstraction, a thought experiment with no axis labelling, and no understanding of whether the axes scales are linear or not. it is therefore completely useless when it comes to making policy, because it provides absolutely no information on whether an X% tax will increase or decrease revenues. there are possible (imaginary) scenarios where the actual shape of the curve will result in increasing tax revenues up to above 90% taxation, and others where revenues drop with anything above 0% taxation. nothing about the concept of "decreasing returns to scale on taxation" is quantitative, and it is therefore essentially useless. I mean, sure, you can make the theoretical argument that "surely above some level of taxation, any further increase will result in decreased revenues", but since it is impossible to know what that level is, the argument is pointless.
- tomrod 4y agoIndeed. Though there are studies that seek to estimate this in various ways (e.g. "no happier once you have $75k in wealth").
- mech765 4y agoIt seems to me that you have confused "decreasing returns" vs "negative returns."
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoin what sense?
- tomrod 4y agoNegative returns could indeed happen in cases of enforcement cost increases, but otherwise I think you're right.