4 ms·
Riiight, but disabling the volume buttons on a phone is an extreme edge case in the functionality one might expect from their phone. Non-rooted Android still ha
by untog 15y ago
Riiight, but disabling the volume buttons on a phone is an extreme edge case in the functionality one might expect from their phone. Non-rooted Android still has 99.9% of the functionality the average user expects.
but I've run into many other hurdles trying to do simple tasks due to the 'security' design they've put into Android
Maybe I'm cynical, but I think that the average user absolutely needs this security design. They'd probably turn off the volume buttons by mistake then think their phone is broken.
- kruhft 15y agoIf you keep treating average users as average users they will always be...average users.
- VMG 15y agoIf you start treating them as system administrators and software engineers they will be frustrated users. After that they will be users of a competing product.
- kruhft 15y agoGiving the ability to do system administration tasks on a device you own is not treating people like system administrators. It's giving someone the ability to work on, modify and learn about (and break (and fix)) their device if they so choose.
- kruhft 15y agoYikes, one would think that a site called Hacker News would be a bit nicer to someone talking about enabling people through learning about technology. No wonder I started my own version: http://kruhft.dyndns.org http://kruhft.dyndns.org
- untog 15y agoThat's a pretty transparent spammy plug for your site, there. I think the general point is that the average user is never going to a sysadmin, and nor is it fair to expect that of them.
- kruhft 15y agoI wouldn't say I was spamming but promoting an alternative place where people that think that having root on and having control over your own phone is a good thing and won't get down voted for it. At least that was the point when I wrote the original, as you say spammy, comment.
- kruhft 15y agoReply to untog: yes it's a plug for my site, deal with it. With all the meta-discussion lately about this site and how it's gone downhill, maybe I feel it's time to try and create a new one that lives a bit more up to the name Hacker. No, the average user won't be a sysadmin, but what about their kids? (Oh god, did I just do a think of the children?)
- kruhft 15y agoWatching my karma on this conversation has been interesting. It's gone from +10 above to -2 below what it was before. Must be a touchy subject.
- Tichy 15y agoWell Google gives you the ability to root their phones, what more do you want? You don't have to hack it, rooting the phone is a standard procedure. Of course you should stick to the Nexus line. But if you are knowledgeable enough to be an admin, you probably already knew that.
- kruhft 15y agoYes I do know that. I didn't root my GF's phone because I wanted a stock phone around for doing testing when I do app development.