7 ms·
Toward policy for open-source software as infrastructure
- neilv 4y agoThe cover image, of grievously mutated minifigs, surrounded by the guts of surreal machinery strewn about the floor... represents a dire situation of open source infrastructure? (I can't tell whether it's Stable Diffusion or intentional.)
- mathgladiator 4y ago100% I try to generate images for my blog and technical things come out like madness
- kleene_op 4y agoThose lego figs have seen better days, that's for sure.
- perihelions 4y agoOh, "figurines"! I was looking for a fruit.
- userbinator 4y agoI'd say it's definitely some sort of AI image generation.
- none_to_remain 4y agoThe classic comic applies: Nerd: I made this! DC/Brussels: You made this? DC/Brussels: I made this!
- bee_rider 4y agoThis seems to mostly be a policy piece, targeted at political folks rather than technical ones. The laborious establishment of a couple analogies was particularly hard to get through, but I suppose it will be useful for the target audience. A concern with this sort of thing is that it will have weird expectations about developer responsibility in securing the, as they like to call it, “software supply chain.” It was nice to see that that they reiterated the open source developers basically have no responsibility. I don’t see too much objectionable here, no idea if they proposals would actually help but they seem mostly harmless. An analogy that occurred to me while reading was: open source developers could be seen as more like a natural resource, something like wild animals. In particular wild bees. People don’t really expect bees to follow many instructions. You can set up nice places for them to put their hives. But mostly you should just leave them alone and be happy to collect the honey they produce, which they produce as a side effect of existing — you can check if you want to eat it.
- RobotToaster 4y ago>You can set up nice places for them to put their hives. Paying their rent would be a good start, and like bees, make them more productive.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI'm going to be that guy and point out that Free and Open Source are two related but separate concepts. An open source dev can still charge for his code, and should if he needs/wants to make a living off of it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tremon 4y agoSo can a Free Software developer, so what point are you trying to make with your first sentence?
- Dalewyn 4y agoWe have no obligation to pay their rent because they explicitly waived such desires. EDIT: I realize I failed at reading comprehension. Apologies. Free-as-in-libre runs counter to asking for payment because they, as far as my layman understanding is concerned, are mutually exclusive. Code can't be free-as-in-libre if you have to pay monies to get any rights thereof. Open source, on the other hand, is just that: The source is open for viewing. You can read the code at your leisure, but what you can do with the code or the knowledge gained from reading it is an entirely different matter. So a free dev fundamentally can't charge for his code, but an open source dev can charge for his code.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoFree-as-in-libre means you don't have to pay for code itself, as it exists at a given moment. You can, but don't have to. However, that doesn't mean Free Software becomes completely detached from the economy - on the contrary, it's actually meant to empower the economy, in particular smaller and local economies. That's because labor isn't free. Say the code, as is, solves 90% of the problem. To get to 100%, you need some changes to be made. That is, you need to get someone - the original author(s), or a third party - to make them for you. They're not obliged to do it for free - only to release such changes for free to everyone's benefit. So you have to pay someone. The license just makes sure everyone benefits, and that incremental benefits need to be only paid for once. Additionally, code alone isn't a solution. Any kind of deployment, hosting, management, etc. involves labor, whether in-house, hired, or from a service provider. Again, the code commands money to be moved to those providing value by building up on it. The license only makes sure nobody gets to treat the code itself as their exclusively-owned capital.
- loufe 4y agoI find a lot of things tending towards "governments should fund this". I agree in principal that, at least in this case, everyone should collectively fund this. I don't understand how diverging ability to tax (given gross, massive, uncontrolled tax avoidance) and increasing pressures to fund as society grows more complex (and just/fair/compassionate?) and we realize we have difficult, not-profit-solution-compatible problems are ever going to meet. What's the all-encompassing solution? Our problems are that we cannot continue into debt infinitely, we are struggling to implement basic global tax norms (real, true minimums), there will always be inter-country competition for capital, people will always hate being taxed, we cannot ignore problems indefinitely. Has anyone else been feeling this way?
- moremetadata 4y agoA couple of points. Govt's dont make what they fund, its nearly always outsourced including but not exclusively the decision making. You want Govt's to fund roads, a roads laying and maintenance is nearly always outsourced to a business. On the point of this software, does open source software really matter when its still going to be run on a closed source cpu of sorts. Your network switches, are just highly optimised cpu's for the job of routing, which is still closed source. Even something like ARM on the RaspberryPi is closed source BLOB's. At best, this is like arguing for legislation to made available online when previously it was only available from the parliamentary library's or some of limited and specific journal like the thegazette.co.uk for company related announcements. However all my internet access comes from private businesses, so how would open source software be of benefit to me, when most people are still using a private provider. Even Broadcom provide most of the broadband cabinets here in the UK which is a private business last time I checked. Its a nice idea, but impractical in practice.
- goodpoint 4y agoSemiconductors, computers, fiber optics, airplanes, satellites, the telephone and many other technologies came out from primarily tax-funded R&D...
- mouse_ 4y ago"open-source software" isn't good enough when Microsoft has already embraced and extended it.
- userbinator 4y ago...and the next step is no longer extinguish, but enslave.
- nuker 4y agoJust stop using Windows. Here, fixed this for you.
- indymike 4y agoI don't want this. It doesn't make me interested in sharing more code.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWhat a strange wandering analogy-laden article. The actual benefits of open-source software to governments are pretty clear: 1) Many government services and programs rely heavily on software. Private vendors who supply proprietary software solutions to governments at high cost could be replaced by open-source solutions maintained by government employees, with the core code for each critical package updated regularly and checked constantly for security flaws by a separate entity. 2) Note that in this scenario, a great many techs across a wide variety of government agencies would be responsible for installing, monitoring, updating etc. their local systems, but the actual job of developing and maintaining the code body would be the job of another entity - something like a government-funded academic foundation. So yes, uninstall Windows across the board and install Linux. Huge savings right there. See Brazil, 2005: https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/29/technology/brazil-free-softwares-biggest-and-best-friend.html https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/29/technology/brazil-free-so... As far as the actual software-infrastructure interface, i.e. the code that critical infrastructure from the FAA to the trains to the electricity grid relies upon, let alone the nuclear power plants, well, "Stuxnet" is the first thing that should come to mind. That's a situation were security thinking should come first, and open-source avoids the 'security-through-obscurity' flaw, at least.
- bruce511 4y agoI'm always a bit ambivalent about these sorts of articles. On the one hand if free software is got the greater good, then it makes sense that collective payment would be effecient - and the existing collective payment system we have currently is taxes and govt funding. So yay, let's tap into that. On the other hand this system is grossly ineffecient, and is subject to political oversight. Do we really want them picking and choosing winners and losers? This sort of funding also leads to stagnation. United Launch Alliance has been happily consuming govt $ for 5 decades, with very little improvement in tech. SpaceX comes along to show what can be done by adding a bit of ambition. (and I understand they sell to govt now, but they started with private money.) At the root of this discussion is the fact that Open Source / Free Software has yet to figure out the right funding model. We all agree that the current outcomes are positive, that competition is healthy, that Open access is desirable, but after 4 decades of trying we still don't know how to effeciently fund it. Donations are a bust. Companies aren't set up to pay for things altruistically, and govt funding would (IMO) likely corrupt the system, and incentize gaming-for-grants rather than making better software. Plus those you most need the $ will discover that applying and getting govt funds can result in a lot (I mean a LOT) of extra paperwork. So yeah, on the one hand more $ in the system is good. But govt $ comes at a cost. And that's before we discuss who actually gets paid if a "project" is funded.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> 4 decades of trying we still don't know how to effeciently fund it. I feel this was the most low-effort trying I've ever seen. I've seen fortune tellers and spiritual healers achieve better results that our industry did at rewarding alturism.
- charcircuit 4y ago>At the root of this discussion is the fact that Open Source / Free Software has yet to figure out the right funding model. It has. The biggest one is that tech companies work on open source software either to accomplish their business needs, commoditizing their complement, recruiting, etc. The money to do this comes from that companies business model / investors.
- pabs3 4y ago
- natmaka 4y agoExisting pertinent organizations: https://ffii.org/ https://ffii.org/ https://openinfra.dev/ https://openinfra.dev/
- walterbell 4y agoThe EU Cyber-Resilience Act would mandate expensive 3rd-party audits for some categories of software (including open-source) before they can be sold commercially, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33594440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33594440 > the big players who can afford certification will be able to use ANY open-source component for free but the people who built it will have a tough time to go to the market because they will require the funds they don't necessarily have. The list of "critical" software categories can be updated by the EU based on perceived cybersecurity risk. It currently includes: Operating systems (server/client/mobile) Hypervisors and container runtimes Public key infrastructure Firewalls for industrial use Routers for industrial use
- bjornsing 4y agoOnly read the executive summary, but that far it just reinforces my view of open source as the road to serfdom for talented engineers. Sure, there’s a line here and there about funding maintenance and security audits, but writing it in the first place should of course be free. I have the greatest respect for Richard Stallman sleeping under his desk at MIT so he could write gcc. But I like to get paid. I like to do business. I would like to write challenging and interest software while living in a house, and yes: partaking in the capitalist system. I don’t like the idea that any challenging and interest work in software must be given away for free.
- pabs3 4y agoThere is no reason to not get paid for writing Free Software in the first place too. Some Free Software companies do that, but there are also things like grants. https://github.com/fossjobs/fossjobs/wiki/resources https://github.com/fossjobs/fossjobs/wiki/resources
- bjornsing 4y agoYes! Wonderful. While my friends who are exceptional lawyers or doctors can look forward to a career with more and more challenging work, an elevated position in society and exceptional earnings, I can look forward to: begging for grants or being employed on the lowest rung of some mega corp. It’s truly wonderful the position we have gotten ourselves into as a profession. ;) /s
- goodpoint 4y agoYou are confusing Open Source and Free Software. Richard Stallman always pushed for reciprocal licensing e.g. GPL. Companies have been pushing against that because they love taking without giving back.
- graderjs 4y agoThat's crazy that this group (Of VIPs IMO) got involved in this topic. I wonder what this spells? I'd love to be optimistic but the phrases that come to mind are: something wicked this way comes; and, slumbering toward Bethlehem to be born...
- bitL 4y agoThe fact that policy folks (essentially non-productive folks living off other people's work) are considering making unpaid volunteers criminally liable for security bugs leads to a question: how did we end up here?
- flangola7 4y ago[flagged]
- bdw5204 4y agoThis policy paper argues pretty strongly against making unpaid volunteers criminally liable for security bugs. People in the political realm think of tech as "big tech" (their term for FAANG) and are currently trying to come up with solutions to address the societal problems caused by the FAANGs. That's why it's important for people who understand tech to explain the full consequences of their policy ideas to politicians, regulators and others discussing how to regulate tech. It would also help if there were more people from the tech world going into politics because there's a real risk that computer illiterate politicians will pass something stupid or will inadvertently allow FAANG to capture a regulatory agency and use it to crush their smaller competitors.
- bitL 4y agoJust posing the question of criminal liability for FOSS devs is weird. Moreover, all the proposed solutions are "keep the samaritans non-liable", but prevent them from making any money (or just a very low sum/year) off FOSS. What gave these policy makers right to do this? What kind of perverted mind must be present to come up with these arguments?
- esperent 4y ago> "big tech" (their term for FAANG) Big Tech is a way better name than FAANG, I hope it catches on. FAANG sounds way cooler than the reality of these terribly dull companies and is also very US centric.
- Haga 4y ago[dead]