3 ms·
You self-promote here often¹ (not judging, just an observation), and here are some thoughts that have occurred to me while reading your posts and comments. • Y
by CharlesW 4y ago
You self-promote here often¹ (not judging, just an observation), and here are some thoughts that have occurred to me while reading your posts and comments.
• Your vision for Didget is blurry. Sometimes it's a database (or "general purpose data management system"), sometimes it's a file system. Products that are dessert toppings and floor waxes rarely find purchase. My advice: Decide which problem domain you're playing in, then which problem(s) within that domain this solves.
• The Postgres comparison seems naive. As the Postgres wiki notes, "PostgreSQL ships with a basic configuration tuned for wide compatibility rather than performance. Odds are good the default parameters are very undersized for your system." A comparison with a system-appropriate Postgres configuration would be more interesting.
• Promoting a new closed-source database seems anachronistic when there's a plethora of fine open-source options. If you're wondering why you're not getting many leads from HN, I'd imagine this is the main reason.
¹ https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=didgets.com&sort=byPopularity&type=all https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- didgetmaster 4y agoWhenever I mention my project's website in an HN comment, I am 'self-promoting' so you are correct. In my experience that is not something that is frowned upon on HN, since I see this kind of thing all the time (the article I commented on was promoting another product). Didgets, as it exists today, is a technology rather than a 'product'. It consists of a set of highly optimized data objects that can be used to build complex systems like hierarchical file systems, relational database tables, logging frameworks, configuration managers, or content indexers. I have implemented enough functionality into the browser application to prove that it can do those things well, but none of them are fully implemented yet. I am trying to find the right product-market fit. I have not yet open-sourced any of the code, but I probably will once I decide which open source licensing is best for it. I am simply trying to introduce this technology to others to see if there is any interest in it. Note: While I didn't explore every configuration option in Postgres so I don't have confidence that it ran as fast as it possibly could, I did not just use the default configuration. I tried all the usual tricks to speed it up.
- CharlesW 4y ago> It consists of a set of highly optimized data objects that can be used to build complex systems like hierarchical file systems, relational database tables, logging frameworks, configuration managers, or content indexers. That sounds like a "general-purpose database", unless there's something that disqualifies Didget from being that. If it's a database, you're probably competing with something closer to the free and open-source SQLite than you are the free and open-source Postgres. This can be done (see rqlite), but in any case it seems like being free and open-source would be necessary (although not sufficient) for people to consider it. > I tried all the usual tricks to speed it up. I don't know what "usual tricks" means (maybe you have a link?), but I think it would add some credence to performance claims to specify what you're doing.