6 ms·
The conundrum with mutual aid is that it's non-trivial to identify the right size community for a given type and/or level of aid. For example, a block or 3 of
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
The conundrum with mutual aid is that it's non-trivial to identify the right size community for a given type and/or level of aid.
For example, a block or 3 of mixed income households can certainly help ameliorate temporary "food insecurity" for some of its members. A slightly larger community can probably offer significant aid when it comes to providing at home care for people with temporary illness or ill health.
But ... covering unemployment or serious illness ... these are examples of things that require a much (much) larger societal unit to be really effective. The same is probably true for providing long term at-home care for the elderly or chronically ill.
That doesn't mean that mutual aid makes no sense - there are plenty of good reasons to operate with different types of organization at different levels. It just means recognizing what the limits of a given societal unit are likely to be, and making sure there are other structures/organizations in place to deal with things that go beyond those limits.
- kqr 4y ago> But ... covering unemployment or serious illness ... these are examples of things that require a much (much) larger societal unit to be really effective. Really? How many hours of labour per year does it actually take to feed, shelter and provide medical care for a person? I'd be surprised if it was more than 20 % of the hours I work today, meaning I could – barring a system that concentrates the spoils of my labour in the hands of the few – provide this assistance for four people besides myself. As you may know, the unemployed and seriously ill number fewer than half of the population, so I think we'd be fine. I mean yes, that stuff takes specialisation, and that probably requires a larger community. (If only 0.1 % of the population are medical doctors, then we need 1000 people to have one doctor). But those numbers sort of work out in the world today, so I don't know why they wouldn't in a different world.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> How many hours of labour per year does it actually take to feed, shelter and provide medical care for a person? To medieval standards of medical care and food, sure. Past that we need training and specialisation, both of which increase the number of people the average person can support.
- ryanmcbride 4y agoThe standard of care many americans get is already well below medieval standard (none)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> standard of care many americans get is already well below medieval standard (none) This is nonsense. Emergency care, accessible to all, is practically magic compared to that time. And preventative care largely wasn’t a thing.
- kevviiinn 4y agoAs long as you're okay with being bankrupt
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> long as you're okay with being bankrupt One, dead or debilitated versus bankrupt. Two, no: Medicaid, charity, et cetera. It’s not a good system. But comparing it to pre-medical care is stupid beyond belief.
- kevviiinn 4y agoCharity and medicare don't cover everyone. There are people who make a little too much to get on medicare but are still close to the poverty line. Charity is wildly hit or miss with luck as the biggest factor
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> there are people who make a little too much to get on medicare but are still close to the poverty line Yet you're still going to pretend this is the same as nobody having medicine.
- tomrod 4y agoThe argument of linear transfers, which is "my work could feed five people," seems logically false since there is a very real marginal productivity incentive. If your job pays you 20% of your current salary, do you want to work as hard? Typically, though of course not always, the answer will be no. You'll work less, you'll take on less high-effort-required activities, and so on. This effectively means transfers are subadditive and you couldn't perform such algebra across a society. EDIT: Note for the numerous driveby downvoters that have failed to engage in discussion, thereby decreasing the quality of conversation. I am not against using wealth transfers where appropriate. My comment simply calls out that "my work is enough to feed five people" does not equate to "my work will feed five people through wealth transfers."
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think you have a fair point, but it is important to note that the drop off in effort and utility depend on whether the worker is directly involved in the support of others. That is to say, it is very different if I take 20% of my time and directly give it to someone as support versus if I just trust that 20% of my time is taxed and somehow makes it too to one of 350 million people in the country.
- tomrod 4y agoCorrect. There are decreasing returns to scale on taxation (which also justifies the Laffer curve/supply side/Voodoo economics, but that's another set of philosophical problems). The literature on optimal taxation is large and interesting.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI agree that someone could make an argument about losses and effectiveness, but my point was even simpler than that. When it comes to someone's willingness to work more to help another, I think contact and proximity to the recipient plays a big factor in what people are willing to do.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoWe're not discussing a different world, we're discussing this one. Your doctor example is a good one. If you actually need 1000 people to have 1 doctor, and 1 doctor can treat and care for 999 people, then you need a community of around 1000 people to have "mutual aid" function for medical care (or very good luck in happening to have a doctor in a smaller community). This means that mutal aid care based in units of city blocks is not likely to work, but basing it in units of neighborhoods or larger probably will.
- mharig 4y agoJust to put your numbers to reality: I just roughly estimated the density of doctors in my childhood in 70s Germany: around 1:5000 to 1:10000. And the density of psychologists/psychatrists was around 1:100000. IMHO, that was and is enough.
- aschearer 4y ago> How many hours of labour per year does it actually take to feed, shelter and provide medical care for a person? If said person has Parkinsons, dementia, etc. the medical care/assistance alone is likely to be measured in hours per day. Easily approaching most of one's waking hours for bad cases. As boomers enter senescence the strain on the healthcare system will be immense, I predict. Whole lot of asses to wipe.
- soco 4y agoIf only we had things like mutual savings banks, or cooperative insurances, or...
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoi never mentioned savings banks as an example requiring large scale. and indeed, they appear to need the "more than a block or 2, less than a city" scale. health insurance is a different story, at least in the era of modern health care where particular treatments can cost tens or hundreds of thousands of currency units. it is hard to make the insurance pool concept work without enough people (and enough health-diversity) in the pool. In my home state (new mexico) this is a problem given a state-wide population of only 2M people and multiple insurance possibilities. i don't know what the limit is, but i'd guess that it's at least several hundred thousand and possible a few million.
- runarberg 4y agoPublic health insurance seems to work fine for Iceland—a country of less than 400,000. I suspect dozens of thousands should be plenty given a healthy and diverse economy and plenty of preventative care.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoGood data point - thanks.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIt also works in Liechtenstein, which is approx. 39000 folks.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoNow that does seem surprising. The insurance system is entirely internal to Liechtenstein ?
- GoodJokes 4y ago[dead]
- kerkeslager 4y ago> The conundrum with mutual aid is that it's non-trivial to identify the right size community for a given type and/or level of aid. I don't think this is actually a hard problem at all. The algorithm is quite simple: 1. Start with the individual as the smallest community (a community of one). 2. Does the current level of community have the resources to deal with the problem? If so, problem solved, exit. 3. If not, go to the next larger level of community. 4. Return to 2. The problem is that greedy people refuse to provide aid because they don't think they'll need aid. In fact, greedy people insist on acquiring all the resources which could be used to provide aid to others. Zuckerberg or Musk could end homelessness in the US easily and still be in the top 10 richest people in the world.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> Does the current level of community have the resources to deal with the problem? and you propose to establish this how, precisely? ps. I'm skeptical about the "end homelessness" claim. I agree that (a) the current superrich should be forced to give up some of their wealth (b) that most of it should be diverted towards the poor (c) it would help many of them substantially. However, problems like poverty (and its sidekick, homelessness) are systemic, and recurrent. The US has spent several trillion since the 1960s on poverty, and while it caused a substantial reduction in levels of poverty (especially among the elderly), poverty remains with us as a problem. So by all means take from the rich and give to the poor, but don't expect that to "end" poverty.
- kerkeslager 4y ago> and you propose to establish this how, precisely? Depends on the community. Doesn't mean it's difficult. > The US has spent several trillion since the 1960s on poverty, and while it caused a substantial reduction in levels of poverty (especially among the elderly), poverty remains with us as a problem. The US has spent several trillion on "end poverty" theater. US anti-poverty programs are intentionally designed to exclude as many people as possible. Much of the money spent, is spent on ensuring that people who conservatives have decided don't deserve aid, don't get aid, with reams of paperwork to validate that those in need are deserving. These barriers are severe enough to prevent many people from even being able to apply, and instead of reducing the barriers, the solution has been to pay case workers to leap some of the barriers for those in need--not only does this not work, it also is expensive. The solution to homelessness is homes. Not shelters where you have no privacy or ownership of the space where you can keep pets or possessions. Homes. This is not complicated. Poverty, mental illness, bigotry, unemployment, etc., are all related problems, but they don't have to be solved to solve homelessness. Look at Zuckerberg and Musk's net worths, then look at the number of homeless, then look at the cost of land and building a modest house, and do some napkin math. Yes, I'm aware a sudden demand for housing would drive up the cost of land and building houses: double it and the numbers still work. Yes, there are other potential issues, but none of them are unsolvable. We need to stop pretending this is more complicated than it is.
- dennis_jeeves1 4y ago>require a much (much) larger societal unit to be really effective. Larger, yes, and also I might add smarter. When groups that are not so smart get larger they're prone to politics and/or corruption and/or infighting. Nation states are a classic example.