4 ms·
From the submitted article's last paragraph: "None of this makes the moon a wellspring, and it would have a long way to go before it became a remotely hospitabl
by tokenadult 15y ago
From the submitted article's last paragraph: "None of this makes the moon a wellspring, and it would have a long way to go before it became a remotely hospitable place." The remainder of that paragraph speculates away the logical consequences of that sentence. Overall, the key fact about permanently shaded areas of the Moon, the places with the most water (and not much at that), is that they are extraordinarily cold. Figuring out ways to mine and extract the frozen water in such dark and cold conditions might be a lot more expensive and technically difficult than simply bringing along water from home.
- pstuart 15y agoSounds like a job for Thorium Man! http://www.ted.com/talks/kirk_sorensen_thorium_an_alternative_nuclear_fuel.html http://www.ted.com/talks/kirk_sorensen_thorium_an_alternativ...
- burgerbrain 15y agoWell, that dark problem at least seems pretty easy to solve at least.
- bdunbar 15y agoFiguring out ways to mine and extract the frozen water in such dark and cold conditions might be a lot more expensive and technically difficult than simply bringing along water from home. Best guess [1] for cost to lift a kilo/liter to orbit is $20,000 per. Have to be real expensive to mine water to make it more expensive than shipping the stuff from the Pacific. [1] It is surprisingly hard to tease out data on this value: government accounting is partly to blame. Also: FedEx does not (yet) list their rates for 'delivery to LEO'
- bh42222 15y agoIs that $20,000 for the cost from the earth to the moon? Because I would guess you could escape moon gravity and fall towards earth for a lot less than $20,000 per liter. And large chunks of ice, hurled from the moon, would just melt in our atmosphere. Which is OK if you don't care to deliver water to anyone in particular and just want more of it on earth. You know, in case global warming doesn't raise sea levels enough. Just send solar powered robots at in initial cost of $20,000 per kilo to mine the ice, and have them hurl it at earth for a lot less than $20,000 per liter.
- DanBC 15y agouh, you're sending water the wrong way. $20,000 is cost of taking Earth water into space, and hopefully dumping it on the moon. That's compared to however much it is for existing moon-dwellers to setup and mine water from the moon.
- jxcole 15y agoIt's kind of hard to put a simple number on that (of course, you could have done tons of research to support this, I'm not sure). But it turns out one of the ordinary byproducts of ordinary rockets is water, which is why all space food is dehydrated. This means that if you sent a rocket with nothing on it at all (zero payload) it would arrive at the moon with water. Of course I don't know how much and it is still likely to be ridiculously expensive.
- bdunbar 15y agoof course, you could have done tons of research to support this, I'm not sure Not tons, but some, in support of work for a prior employer. But it turns out one of the ordinary byproducts of ordinary rockets is water, which is why all space food is dehydrated. More like 'a particular fuel that can be used in a rocket is ..' But actually I'm not sure what you're talking about, sorry. Can you expand and correct my knowledge? Rocket fuel goes out the back end, pushes the rocket forward, right? The water is stored in tanks which astronauts draw out to rehydrate their tang?
- ncavig 15y agoPlease indulge my ignorance... Maybe a chemist or someone better versed can answer; are we close, or is it plausible to construct a star trek like replicator to rearrange atoms to form new substances such as water?
- dangrossman 15y agoIt's complete science fiction at this point and there are scientists that argue it will stay that way forever. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drexler%E2%80%93Smalley_debate_on_molecular_nanotechnology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drexler%E2%80%93Smalley_debate_... But who knows. Maybe when society is so advanced that we have infinite power from controlled fusion, extremely accurate and high powered lasers and magnetic field generators, and quantum computers, we'll be able to build a box that moves around individual atoms to construct something.
- eru 15y agoThough that doesn't mean that nanotechnology is impossible. In fact, nanomachines in the form of microbes precede any macromachines. We are getting better and better at controlling microbes. Though we won't be able to use genetic programming on microbes alone to make a cake or steak from scratch.
- eru 15y agoYou can form water from recombining oxygen and hydrogen. Or from material that contain oxygen and hydrogen. Making water out of anything else, is possible in molecular quantities at an exorbitant price using a particle accelerator (or so). So in practice, impossible. A Star Trek Replicator, even one that doesn't transmute different elements into each other and just re-arranges them, is a long way off. The best current design we have is called an ecosystem and uses plants, fungi, animals, other life forms and sun light.
- Symmetry 15y agoTo mostly mirror what eru said, we can easily combine hydrogen and oxygen just by burning them together. You can also extract amounts of oxygen and hydrogen from more complex substances and turn them into water through the magic of that science we know as Chemistry. You should expect that this will generally take a bunch of energy, though. Nanotechnology has the potential to let us construct much more complicated sorts of chemical structures. It would be really neat, but wouldn't really change how much energy it takes to separate water out of other materials, and would probably be a lot less energy efficient than standard industrial methods.