3 ms·
> The game is now antisemitic too, because it contains some ancient horn artifact? No. The game is accused of being antisemitic because it portrays goblins wit
by krapp 4y ago
> The game is now antisemitic too, because it contains some ancient horn artifact?
No. The game is accused of being antisemitic because it portrays goblins with antisemitic stereotypes - greedy, gold-hoarding, hook-nosed bankers and money-lenders.
Although this isn't entirely exclusive to JKR, as Tolkein had similar issues with his original portrayal of dwarves (which he later tried to rectify,) and this sort of portrayal goes far back in folklore and was purposely rooted in antisemitism. Given JKR's other views and her recent open hostility towards what you would consider "the woke", people aren't willing to assume she was simply naive.
If you're interested in the context surrounding this controversy here are some sources. A google search can uncover more.
[0]https://www.forbes.com/sites/danidiplacido/2022/01/05/the-harry-potter-anti-semitism-controversy-explained/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/danidiplacido/2022/01/05/the-ha...
[1]https://www.jta.org/2023/02/10/culture/are-the-goblins-in-the-new-harry-potter-video-game-really-antisemitic https://www.jta.org/2023/02/10/culture/are-the-goblins-in-th...
- linuxftw 4y ago> No. The game is accused of being antisemitic because it portrays goblins with antisemitic stereotypes - greedy, gold-hoarding, hook-nosed bankers and money-lenders. I don't believe anyone actually thinks this. I do believe that people are reaching for any reason to try to disparage the game because they don't like JKR. Maybe, just maybe, the people complaining about the game are unhinged.
- krapp 4y ago> Maybe, just maybe, the people complaining about the game are unhinged. They aren't, but the vibe of this thread already makes it obvious that argument to that end would be fruitless.
- iinnPP 4y agoI would honestly say that anyone linking the goblin behaviour to human behaviour is the racist/prejudice one. Just stop acknowledging that the stereotype is in any way real. Treat it like a child calling you poopiface(which is their best attempt at hurting you btw). That is the ONLY way to beat racism. Even then, racists will be around being racist. The difference is that everyone will treat their opinion the same way they treat the child calling them poopiface. What happens next? The impact of racism is greatly lessened. That is the best case scenario because the only other method involves slavery and reeducation camps. People still murder right? We all agree that is wrong and look at where that gets us. The people who choose to not agree end up where? Right, slavery and reeducation in a camp.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- slenk 4y agoI think the only people making that goblin reference are people looking to be mad. Do you really think tales of dwarfs and goblins didn't exist before people cared about races so much? I'm just baffled by the reaching here. Let people play a video game.
- tomjen3 4y agoCaring about races is very new, but Jews have been the subject of anti-semetic attacks for at least a thousand years, probably twice that.
- TMWNN 4y agoFrom the Forbes piece: >worse, was the Star of David pattern, clearly visible on the floor of Gringotts Bank (this was a feature of the filming location, London’s High Commission of Australia, and did not appear in subsequent films) The star is, specifically, the Commonwealth Star <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_Star https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_Star>. Quite understandably a feature of Australia House, and 100% nothing at all to do with Judaism. "worse", indeed.