5 ms·
A reasonable argument. But 2038? What about taking the artists original intentions and desires in mind? Would MLK want people to pay $20 to watch his speech?
by ck2 15y ago
A reasonable argument. But 2038? What about taking the artists original intentions and desires in mind?
Would MLK want people to pay $20 to watch his speech?
- sp332 15y ago"Intentions" don't mean much if they're not in writing. MLK could have put the speech under a freer license if he wanted to.
- chadmalik 15y agoI think that comment just about sums up the absurdity of the entire "intellectual property" regime. A leftist crusader for equality and advancement of humanity who risked and gave his life in the service now has a bunch of corporate leeches jealously guarding access to and profiting from his most famous speech. I shudder to think what world culture would look like if the intellectual property regime as it now stands were in place from the beginning of recorded history.
- thesteamboat 15y agoWhat freer licenses existed in 1963?
- sp332 15y agoYou really don't need a pre-made license, like one of the Creative Commons licenses. Just grant the use of the speech and recordings of the speech for any purpose. Or make the text of the speech free for noncommercial use.
- icebraining 15y agoWhy would it have to already exist? Anyone can create a license. Pretty sure some lawyer would've done it for free.
- burgerbrain 15y agoJust about anybody in recorded history could have created the phonograph. It's a dead simple concept, even the Mesopotamians probably could have managed it, all you need is a needle (probably could be bone), something to scratch lines into with it (wax for instance, maybe the clay they used for tablets), and some sort of diaphragm (leather should work nicely). Just imagine, we could have voice recordings of Alexander the Great, or Gautama Buddha.... that would be fucking wild. Nobody did it until Edison in the late 19th century. Why? Because the idea of doing something is in most cases more elusive than the ability to do so.
- sp332 15y agoRights were already being sold for printing, delivering, and televising speeches. It would not have been a new idea to license those rights.
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe idea is licensing designed to keep a work free, not licensing designed to restrict. Even if that idea existed at the time, it was not prominent, evidenced by the lack of stock licenses to do so at the time. As you say, "Rights were already being sold".
- monochromatic 15y ago"I hereby dedicate this to the public domain" would probably have sufficed.
- burgerbrain 15y agoPersonal question: Do you believe that this speech not being in the public domain promotes the progress of science and useful arts?
- sp332 15y agoMy opinion isn't the one that matters. And of course the law would have to apply equally to everyone. We can't make exceptions for speeches we would really like to have in the public domain vs. boring speeches. I don't think the Berne convention is perfect, but generally, I like the idea that "As soon as a work is 'fixed', that is, written or recorded on some physical medium, its author is automatically entitled to all copyrights in the work, and to any derivative works unless and until the author explicitly disclaims them, or until the copyright expires." (wikipedia)
- burgerbrain 15y agoHey mate, I'm not asking you for a legally binding decision, I'm just asking your opinion on the matter. I suppose I'll have to assume you don't think that it does, since you're evading the question.
- sp332 15y agoYour question was a non sequitur, quoting a piece of the constitution (which applies to all works made in the US equally) and then asking my opinion about one specific speech. I would say that, now that the speech is made, it would be good to have it in the public domain. But if we put all the speeches in the public domain, professional speechwriters would find it much harder to make a living. So in general, I wouldn't recommend that kind of behavior. To answer your question, I don't think MLK's speech was either science nor a "useful art" so it wouldn't have an effect either way.
- burgerbrain 15y agoIf you don't think the question of benefit to society is relevant to this discussion.... well, that isn't my problem. "if we put all the speeches in the public domain, professional speechwriters would find it much harder to make a living" Yeah. If I were to give a public performance of this speech in my public library that would really hurt speechwriters. I'll give you a hint, it works like this: Person A needs a speech. They ask Person B to write one. Person B agrees in exchange for money. They both sign a contract. Person A receives the speech. Person B gets paid per the contract. Person A gives the speech. Person C through Z copy the speech and give it themselves. Nobody cares.
- brudgers 15y agoThe lawsuit granting copyright protection was filed in 1963 when Dr. King was very much alive.
- monochromatic 15y agoIf he intended the speech to be in the public domain, he would have put it in the public domain... either during his life, or via his will. That fact that he didn't says more about his intentions than any of our after-the-fact speculation.
- chc 15y agoI'm not sure it's exactly a ringing endorsement of the Copyright Act of 1976 that Martin Luther King Jr. didn't take the time out of his civil rights campaign to work out the copyright status of everything he ever said in the less than half a decade between the time he gave this speech and his untimely death.
- monochromatic 15y agoFrom the article: "King himself donated proceeds from licensing the speech to fund the civil rights movement" This sure makes it sound like he wasn't ignorant of copyright law and its impact on his speeches.
- chc 15y agoThis sure makes it sound to me like he was more concerned with the civil rights movement of the 1960s than with the copyright status of his speech in 2025. EDIT: Come on, downvoters — do you really mean to suggest that King would have wanted a civil rights memorial to have to pay out his family before it could celebrate his cause?