3 ms·
Sabine Hossenfelder tweets sarcastically on this. https://twitter.com/skdh/status/1623728595297345538 https://twitter.com/skdh/status/1623728595297345538
by pfdietz 4y ago
Sabine Hossenfelder tweets sarcastically on this.
https://twitter.com/skdh/status/1623728595297345538 https://twitter.com/skdh/status/1623728595297345538
- messe 4y agoRelevant xkcd "Linear Regression": https://xkcd.com/1725/ https://xkcd.com/1725/
- kelipso 4y agoFrom one of the authors: "It's not a linear regression. This representation is a typical mistake when using mixed effect statistics. It is a "dyadic regression" which is a complex mixed effects procedure. We avoid such representation for ME but reviewers ask." (https://twitter.com/ulugeyik/status/1623654892639330304 https://twitter.com/ulugeyik/status/1623654892639330304) So there's more to the story but that graph is really easy to make fun of because it looks like a linear regression.
- messe 4y agoInteresting. That's not from the authors though: https://twitter.com/ulugeyik/status/1623749246322089984 https://twitter.com/ulugeyik/status/1623749246322089984
- kelipso 4y agoOh ok, just seemed like it from the way he talked but yeah, it is dyadic regression so there's more the story (no idea what it is) but it's still such a terrible graph that I would never want to put in a paper.
- syzarian 4y agoExpert with controversial opinions in her area of expertise feels qualified to criticize the work of experts in an area she knows nothing about. EDIT: Turns out it’s a dyadic regression and Sabine doesn’t know what she is talking about.
- abnry 4y agoI mean, do you honestly think that the graph represents a good linear fit?
- syzarian 4y agoThe data does not appear to me to represent a function. There is a lot of verticality to the data. It’s doesn’t appear to me to be logistic, exponential, or a higher degree polynomial. What is the best model? I don’t know. I’m not a statistician or a neuroscientist. Maybe they have reasons for doing a linear fit in this case that we aren’t aware of. Typically experts have reasons for what they do and their reasons would seem reasonable to me if I knew what they did.
- dopu 4y agoI don’t know who she is, but you don’t need to be neuroscientist or a statistician to see how laughably bad that correlation claim is.
- syzarian 4y agoI don’t know neuroscience. I do know that sometimes there is so little known about a given area that one has to grasp at straws so to speak. You look for clues and present the findings. I don’t know what one does with the data represented. It appears to me that the data doesn’t represent a function. There’s a lot of “verticality” in the data. It’s obviously not exponential, logarithmic, or parabolic or some other higher degree polynomial. So how does one fit such data? I don’t know. Is it dumb to use linear fit? Or is it common practice with such data?
- jerf 4y agoBrain Thing Correlates With Other Brain Thing is the expected result of any two Brain Things, because all the Brain Things correlate. The failure here is a variant of the Streetlight Effect; we looked for this one correlation, we found it, so it must be important. It's not, unless it's really strong, because in this space, everything correlates to everything. To be important, there needs to be something more than "a correlation"; that's so expected as to be a near zero-bit contribution to science. For there not to be any correlation would actually be the surprising thing!