10 ms·
Elsevier = Evil
- speleding 15y ago"Since Elsevier's obscene additional profits would be drained from America to the company's base in the Netherlands" I agree the proposed act is bad, but the author does not do himself any favors by quoting such bone headed nationalism. Surely anyone with a mild grasp of the way world works knows that the profits go to the _shareholder_, not to the headquarters. Elsevier's shareholders are all over the map. Their headquarters are based in the Netherlands for tax reasons but it does not mean they don't pay tax in the US on profits made there.
- raphman 15y agoMinor correction: Elsevier's headquarters are in Amsterdam for historical reasons, not for tax reasons.
- speleding 15y agomy wife used to work as a tax attorney for Elsevier in Amsterdam and while it is true the company was founded in the Netherlands (Haarlem actually), the main reason they are still there are the excellent "tax facilities" (euphemism for a great deal with the tax man).
- hessenwolf 15y agoA surprisingly large number of companies have a 'great deal' with the tax man behind closed doors whether in US or elsewhere. Published corporate tax rates are, admittedly anecdotally but from good sources, not representative of what corporations actually pay. Understandably, a company providing jobs and infrastructure investment in the local area can always strike a deal.
- raphman 15y agoI stand at least partially corrected. Sorry and thank you.
- obtu 15y agoHere is an in-depth report on how the Netherlands is a tax-haven for multinationals: http://somo.nl/html/paginas/pdf/netherlands_tax_haven_2006_NL.pdf http://somo.nl/html/paginas/pdf/netherlands_tax_haven_2006_N... . IKEA (the world's largest charity) is an egregious example. A participation exemption allows corporate income and dividends to be channelled to a country with very low tax.
- soyelmango 15y agoThe Economist on Ikea: http://www.economist.com/node/6919139 http://www.economist.com/node/6919139
- zeeed 15y agoElsevier (or any other company) that uses lobbying or gives money to politicians is just using the system in their favor. That's not evil. It's evil that the system allows for this to happen.
- mjwalshe 15y agoThats a very naive view - laws are often drafted by lawyers / polaticians - and what makes non corporate actors in lobying any better or worse they are just lobbying for their constituents. With your model extremist churches or other organisations could lobby to reduce employment rights for women/LGBT etc. For example returning to the 50's wheer women who got married had to resign like they did at one compnay I used to work for. A company with progressive views on employment issues say Google would be banned from lobbying against this. And you would have od position where say the UAW could put their views on a bill concerning the Auto industry but Alan Mulally could not - not teribly fair.
- jedbrown 15y agoTwo problems: 1. Money is an extremely effective campaign tool, so effective that it is almost impossible for a candidate with no money to get elected, no matter how popular their views are. Since quite few constituents contribute money, and individual people don't speak with sufficiently organized objectives, politicians are only very weakly accountable to their constituents. 2. The promise of a high-paying job after congress, along with other benefits, influences the decisions of our elected officials. To make politicians accountable to their constituents, we have to solve the first problem. Since advertising costs money and seems to be necessary for a campaign, this suggests finance reform along the lines that Lessig suggests (http://rootstrikers.org http://rootstrikers.org), whereby constituents control campaign funding, all in small-dollar amounts.
- mjwalshe 15y agoYou need to first remove any civil service position from being in the presidents gift as a bribe for contributions no jollies as an ambassador ETC and NO presidential pardons for anything Scooter Libby ought to be in the cell next to Manning or more properly have been taken out and shot. Oh and move to a fully professional Judiciary elections to Judgeship are far more corrupting. Oh and you didn't answer my point about other actors do you want to have an internet where telcos and ISP can't lobby for common carrier status welcome to the church and other interest groups deciding what is allowed on the internet Or would you care live a society like China or Russia where your employer and your job and sweat equity can be expropriated.
- tylerritchie 15y agoReally all NIH and NSF grants should come with open access requirements. I would suggest that all raw data be made available no later than 1 year after initial collection and all publications be open-access upon publishing with curated data also available upon publishing. The "1 year after initial collection" allows slower writers to get publications in the pipeline before unleashing their data to the hounds of "competing" scientists. Scientific publishing is broken. Industry and government have limited access to modern, relevant academic research. Utilizing the best science for science, management, construction and business decisions shouldn't be a daunting task that I usually chose to overcome by contacting current individuals in academics with access to publications.
- mrlase 15y agoWhat is really frustrating about scientific research? Working in a research lab, looking up something you've found from your research in the literature, and then not having access to the article without paying for it. $30 is way too much to be spending on an article that might not even have the content you're looking for as it might not be mentioned in the abstract. (I'm working in a virology lab with a professor at a smaller university and this can be a frequent occurrence, meaning we have to wait for the library to go and get the article for us, hindering our progress). I found out about a pretty cool project called "Total-impact". They're basically tying together metrics from a vast number of social networking/online sources into one view about a specific scientific article to understand how far this research is reaching as well as the overall impact of how many people are talking about it. You can view it at http://total-impact.org/ http://total-impact.org/, and there is a sample collection at http://total-impact.org/collection/MqAnvI http://total-impact.org/collection/MqAnvI. I'd also recommend looking at Science 2.0's FriendFeed, http://friendfeed.com/science-2-0 http://friendfeed.com/science-2-0, as it contains some pretty interesting content. I really hope that the "open science" movement gains more traction in the immediate future.
- pork 15y agoIn response to your suggestion on data being made available, there are often issues of proprietary datasets that cannot be made public (for legal or ownership reasons). It is a frustrating situation, but one that is not likely to change anytime soon, so I would be happy with just the open-access publication requirement.
- kiba 15y agoFor every evil bills that is on the public consciousness, another bill slip by. It's basically a game of whacking a mole.
- tstegart 15y agoHa, but our Congress is so inept they can't write bills faster than we whack them. So it pays to be vigilant.
- boredguy8 15y agoVery interesting to see Darrell Issa (R - CA) as a sponsor on this bill, given how eloquently he's spoken out against SOPA in the Judiciary Committee. Here's the copy of the email I just sent his office: I'll try and contact his office by phone tomorrow. Hello, It's been with great pleasure that I've been able to watch Representa- tive Issa speak out against SOPA in the Judiciary. However, I'm concerned at seeing him offer "H.R.3699 -- Research Works Act" as such an act is a major blow to scientific openness. As you may well be aware, in many nations it's a requirement that re- search receiving federal funds (i.e. research at taxpayer expense) be made available for free to the public. The recent policy proposal by the NIH would move the US towards a similarly open policy and would help foster the openness of research that made this country such a leader in science and technology for so long. Unfortunately, companies like Elsevier have increasingly treated pub- lishing as a private cash cow, banking (in part) on the burgeoning costs of a university education to widen its coffers. The journals published by Elsevier cost colleges and universities millions of dollars each year and burden students with growing debt (and for others, preclude the possibility of higher education at all). I ask that Representative Issa revisit his stand on this issue. Thank you.
- kevinchen 15y agoIs there a searchable list of supporting representatives / organizations as there is for SOPA?
- dangrossman 15y agohttp://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-h3699/show http://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-h3699/show
- patio11 15y agoFWIW, since people don't seem to know this: Dead tree letters >> phone > fax >>> email >>>>>>> any online petition, in terms of how motivated staff are to convey your sentiment up the totem pole. (Anecdotal from brothers' service with a few congressional reps.) [Edit: Sorry, checked on my screen but didn't realize my resolution was too high to show me if it broke lines.]
- RK 15y agoMaybe the silver lining is that a large scale uproar could incline more people to publish in open access journals in the first place (so-called "gold" open access). </wishful thinking>
- jedbrown 15y agoCounter-point: http://scienceinthesands.blogspot.com/2011/12/in-defense-of-submission-in-scientific.html http://scienceinthesands.blogspot.com/2011/12/in-defense-of-...
- obtu 15y agoResearchers are already paying to get their articles published. Given how much journal subscription costs, that cost is a fraction of the taxpayer money that is spent buying back the articles for the university libraries the same researchers use.
- jedbrown 15y agoIt depends what institution you are at and how much research funding you have. If you are a professor at a small teaching university (even in the US), a few publications per year in open access journals is the same cost as supporting a student for a year. Depending on the field and how established you, obtaining research funding can take a lot of time that might be better spent doing actual science. (This is true at all levels, but in high-profile fields, the grant sizes are large enough that publishing costs are almost negligible.) Although I am friends with David (the author of this blog post), I do not agree that open access is fundamentally the wrong model, but his argument is not without merit.
- abrahamsen 15y agoHow much does a "small teaching university" pay for access to scientific journals? I'd guess that a "teaching university" would have nearly the same need for access (if the teaching is any good), but much less need for submission, compared to a "research university", so the teaching university should benefit from shifting cost from access to submission.
- pm90 15y agoElsevier itself has a pretty bad reputation (for overcharging)...Donald Knuth protested about this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier#Resignation_of_editorial_boards http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier#Resignation_of_editori... excerpt: At the end of 2003, the entire editorial board of the Journal of Algorithms resigned to start ACM Transactions on Algorithms with a different, lower priced publisher, at the suggestion of Journal of Algorithms founder Donald Knuth. The actual letter (pdf): http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf
- hokua 15y agoIm not sure why scientists are still publishing in Elsevier journals nowadays. Pre-internet, OK, but now I think journals should be following the model used by the Journal of Machine Learning Research, open on the internet.
- Homunculiheaded 15y agoExactly. The only thing holding academics back is themselves. The current state of academic publishing is ridiculous. I recently submitted something that I had to perform full copy-editing and formatting for. I know this is standard practice in engineering, but that's what publishers used to get paid for. In the end I'll have done the research, the writing, the editing and the formatting but of course the end product will in all likelihood be behind a paywall (this is sort of my own stupidity for rushing to get something published under the advice of a prof). There's no reason individual academic communities can't decide that they should establish there own reputable and open access journals.
- pedrobeltrao 15y agoScientists still publish Elsevier because of the so called "impact factor" of some of these journals. As a young researcher currently looking for tenure-track positions in academia I can tell you that it is still extremely important to publish in some of these journals (ex Cell). Unfortunately there are still very few (or none) open access journals that have the same perceived impact. I try to publish in PLoS journals or other open access journals as much as I can but given the chance to publish in higher impact journals I have to take it or risk not having a job in the future. Once you have the job you need to secure funding and so there is always pressure to publish in the "best" possible journal. The ridiculous thing about this situation is that would be fairly easy to create a new open access and highly prestigious journal in any field if everyone would switch to publishing in these new journals at the same time. You would probably just need to convince some of the leaders in the field to do it. This was how PLoS was born in fact. Unfortunately for the PhD students and postdocs it is hard to do anything about it.
- billswift 15y agoAcademia is mostly about signalling, not entirely, but mostly (see Robin Hanson's http://www.overcomingbias.com http://www.overcomingbias.com posts on academia). Making it difficult and expensive to publish increases the signalling effect and helps keep out the riff-raff.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 15y agoWould somebody please do a startup to provide an alternative to these evil people? It shouldn't be difficult to disrupt them, as you literally need a printer and a webserver.
- Natsu 15y agoLike http://arxiv.org/ http://arxiv.org/ ?
- adrianN 15y agoWhat you need above all else is a reputation and that is much harder to get than a printer and a webserver.
- abrahamsen 15y agoYou don't need a printer, online only is fully acceptable. However, what you do need is an "impact rating" calculated by Web of Science(TM). That rating is based on the number of citations articles in your journal gets from other rated journals. Since your journal is new, it won't have an impact rating, meaning scientists won't publish in it, meaning you won't get an impact rating. But the alternatives exists, e.g. Bentham and Hindawi are both running spamtastic marketing campaigns for 100s of open access journals, most with none or negligible impact ratings. There are good and successful ones too. PLoS have very high quality open access journals. Expensive, though.
- tomjen3 15y agoThere are plenty of academics who don't like the traditional publishing racket. Some of them are bound to have tenure.
- abrahamsen 15y agoThat matters less than you would think. Even with tenure, you typically need research grants in order to have money for research. Research grants are typically granted based on your publishing history in high impact journals. But again, there are good open access journals out there. And even traditional publishers typically allows open access for individual articles for an additional fee. While these fees may seem high, they will typically only constitute a small fraction of a research grant, so if you care and you plan for it in advance, there is really no excuse for not going open access.
- ez77 15y agoPlease change title to "Elsevier == Evil".
- rbanffy 15y ago"=" as a comparator is valid BASIC.
- groovy2shoes 15y agoAnd FORTRAN and Pascal and Scheme and...
- rbanffy 15y agoI think FORTRAN had .EQ. for that...
- zerostar07 15y agoHow about another "Protest" for Open Access? How would that go though, maybe OA advocates could refuse to do article reviews.
- notahacker 15y agoSeems easy enough for the NIH to counter by changing their funding policy to exclude all "private sector research works", leaving academics and universities to decide whether they'd rather carry out research nominally under the auspices of some public sector organisation that handles distribution or not take the funds. If they really wanted to they could even introduce their own peer review process for final publications too... It's remarkably short-sighted and pointless legislation, unless the real objective is to start suing authors for forwarding PDF copies of their work and related documents to interested parties without journal access.