3 ms·
Its paywalled so I can comment initially only to the teaser. He's a "trader" not an investor. amateur traders are quite different to investors. If the article
by ggm 4y ago
Its paywalled so I can comment initially only to the teaser. He's a "trader" not an investor. amateur traders are quite different to investors.
If the article actually says there is a function here for individuals to direct preferences, and somehow "inform the market" well ok, wisdom of crowds.
If the article really means "a giant suck hole of chumps we can rip off because we know more than them, and they have sentiment, and enough stake to lose to make it worthwhile" thats kind of .. wall street bets but in a newspaper.
- shagie 4y agoGift link (no paywall) - https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-retreat-of-the-amateur-investors-11675486817?st=lqxnb85vrkldll2&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-retreat-of-the-amateur-inve...
- ggm 4y agoThanks. As I expected, there's a conflation of day traders, and players against investors. Lots of people acquire things and hold. They pay some intermediary to perform the trades, but they aren't doing active trading, because their investment strategy is buy and hold. So, observations to the size of the amount of non-funds amateur investors? on the money. But assuming their movements is a function of people who read some $25 "how to make money trading from home" seems to me to be faulty journalism. I very much doubt active traders (people with more than one transaction per week let us say) is the scale of the market of concern here. I think its far more likely as people look at income from holding, the relative worth compared to initial investment, and availability of income stream products and investments they're moving out of shares and into other things. Pensioners do that. They're not all get-rich-quick fantasists. The illustration and their quips to returning to $14/h jobs in Vegas are not really a national trend as much as seniors pulling out of direct shares into EFT, or property, or income stream products from banks.
- llampx 4y agoUnless you can and do read financial documents and have a say at the investor relations meetings, you're more likely a trader relying on being able to sell your shares for a greater price than you bought them for, than an investor. Let's be real. 100 shares of a billion or trillion dollar market cap company does not an investor make.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoNo, if you invest you are an investor. The amount you invest is a quantitative attribute, whether you are an "investor", or not is qualitative. You could say that a "Professional Investor" is someone whose main income comes from investing. A "Day Trader" for instance.
- m-ee 4y agoI interned at a prop shop and all the professional traders there very explicitly did not consider themselves investors, they were day traders. The distinction was mostly a matter of time horizon, almost no one held positions overnight. The goal was explicitly to make money trading on price action, not to evaluate which companies or industries would successfully allocate capital over the long term.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI can appreciate that nuance. If you just day-trade it's more like gambling, even though the odds may be better than in Las Vegas.
- bagacrap 4y agoReading financial documents will only give you an illusion that you have some greater chance of success at stock picking. Amateur investors only buy index funds, anything else is speculation.