4 ms·
"should" invites "what imperative, to whose purpose" as a question. "should" the board demand senior executive pay cuts? Why? they're fam. They're part of the
by ggm 4y ago
"should" invites "what imperative, to whose purpose" as a question.
"should" the board demand senior executive pay cuts? Why? they're fam. They're part of the tribe. You cut the slaves, you cut the foreigners, why do you cut family?
"should" investors demand the senior executives get pay cuts? Why? They just executed thousands of slaves, and there will be a massive drop in costs, and the share prices will rise. Why would I punish them, when I am going to benefit?
"should" society at large demand Google and large corporates share the pain?
Well yes, but nobody is going to make them do anything. "should" is the wrong dynamic.
"we" should make them do it demands the question: "who is we here and what is our lever?"
- monero-xmr 4y agoKind of a reach to call some of the highest paid employees on earth slaves
- simple-thoughts 4y agoSociety doesn’t owe an obligation to support highly skilled engineers earning more than $50k per year, and in some cases earning more than $200k a year. These people are going to be fine, yeah they might have to cook their own food and move somewhere cheaper, but calling for society to bail out one of the most advantaged classes is ridiculous.
- woodruffw 4y agoNothing in the GP's comment implies a "bail out," or that they don't understand the immense privilege associated with tech wages. Focusing on that talks past the point: a person can simultaneously be paid handsomely and still underpaid, if their productive output significantly outstrips their salary. The last time I checked, Google's revenue-per-employee was around $1.6 million.
- nickff 4y agoRevenue per employee is a very poor measure of productivity; it would imply that many people working at startups are completely unproductive (which rings false to me).
- woodruffw 4y agoThere is a very literal sense in which working at a early startup is less productive: you're trading current productive capacity for potential future productive capacity. The economics bear this out: early startups pay less, and offer equity to compensate. That's a long way of saying that we shouldn't confuse economic productivity with effort.
- kilgnad 4y agoSociety owes engineers all of civilization. They built it. When I see engineers getting 200k what I see is society as it should be. The majority of wealth should be distributed to the most skilled workers on the bottom. But even at 200k, this is not what is happening in tech companies. The thing that nobody owes anything to is execs. Execs just tell engineers what to build. The injustice that's going on here is just power dynamics that lets executives have unfair safety and engineers get fucked. The irony is that Engineers as a group they are 100000x more powerful then any exec, the issue is engineers don't operate from a place of central authority. This is what unions are for. In times like this it's worth considering.
- piva00 4y agoSolidarity among workers starts with... Solidarity. Privileged or not, they are all salaried, the more we can all agree that if you depend on a salary you are part of the same class of people the more power to workers we get.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoThe economic, political, and social system advantages certain classes of workers over others. Personally, that doesn’t bother me as I am benefiting from the system myself. But to claim solidarity with workers who are not from our class and do not share our values is something I will never stoop to. Instead it’s better to recognize privilege and act in a way that recognizes your class obligations.
- jmeister 4y ago>"should" investors demand the senior executives get pay cuts? Why? They just executed thousands of slaves, and there will be a massive drop in costs Why not? Investors are after every additional cent, and they don’t have special charitable feelings towards execs.
- kilgnad 4y agoThey do. The higher you are up on the ladder the more likely you'll be communicating with board members. Communication implies relationship and all the buddy buddy politics required to even get an executive position.
- ggm 4y agoThis guy gets it. You pay the board big bucks, to not have to worry about their conscience when they cut the labour force to make a short-term win. If you're in the set of people who are just along for the ride (make money, no other buy in to the outcome) then you don't ditch a board until the aircraft is within inches of crashing, and you have another one to jump onto. Google isn't looking for Victor Kiam to replace Sundar. Mind you, it would be "extremely entertaining" if they did. Emphasis on extreme I guess.
- gorbachev 4y agoAlmost all the board members also former executives, so they're already in the same peer group as them. It's also not uncommon, though less so in megacorps, for the board members to be family and friends, or a history of long mutually beneficial relationships.