3 ms·
I recall reading that pointing is something that only a few animals, including us, do and understand. If I get my cats' attention and point at something, they'
by pavel_lishin 4y ago
I recall reading that pointing is something that only a few animals, including us, do and understand.
If I get my cats' attention and point at something, they're more interested in the tip of my finger than the direction I'm pointing at.
Now, my cats will occasionally meow to get my attention and then walk over to where the problem is - an empty food dish, an empty water bowl, the bed that they expect us to be in because hello, it's bedtime according to my internal cat-clock - but they never engage in pointing behavior.
Anyway, time to cite some stuff, instead of dropping anecdotes into a bucket:
- https://www.wired.co.uk/article/elephant-pointing https://www.wired.co.uk/article/elephant-pointing
> A study by researchers from the University St Andrews has found that elephants are the only wild animals that can understand human pointing without being trained.
> Pointing in humans is a behaviour that develops at a very early age -- usually before a child reaches 12 months – as it is an immediate way of controlling the attention of others. "Most other animals do not point, nor do they understand pointing when others do it," says Professor Richard Byrne, one of the authors of the study. "Even our closest relatives, the great apes, typically fail to understand pointing when it's done for them by human carers; in contrast, the domestic dog, adapted to working with humans over many thousands of years and sometimes selectively bred to follow pointing, is able to follow human pointing -- a skill the dogs probably learn from repeated, one-to-one interactions with their owners."
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7531526_A_comparative_analysis_of_animals'_understanding_of_the_human_pointing_gesture https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7531526_A_comparati...
> If the distance between the tip of the indexfinger and the object was greater than 50 cm, subjects per-formed poorly in contrast to trials where the pointing fingeralmost touched the baited box. We should also note that insome trials/experiments the pointers also turned their headand looked in the same direction thereby enhancing thecommunicative effect of the gesture but even so the differ-ence did not disappear. Even after training, chimpanzees in Povinellietal’s (1997) experiment were just able to master the task.
- PaulHoule 4y agoBy "pointing" I don't mean pointing your finger, the universal version of "pointing" involves your eyes, shoulders and the rest of your body. (Think of a how a hunting dog points... Plenty of times I've seen cats point out things to other cats not to mention to me.)
- soiler 4y agoThose behaviors could be better described as "looking" and "facing", couldn't they? Pointing means something pretty specific to humans, especially when we're talking about human-animal interactions.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI'd agree with GP here - pointing with a finger is a very specific variant, that's arguably cultural in nature. More fundamentally, pointing is about communicating to the other being they should focus their attention elsewhere, and where that elsewhere is. "Looking"/"facing" and associated body language is a more common form of doing this, and humans too do it and recognize it, even if no fingers are being moved.
- harrisontan 4y agoFrom an evolutionary/physiology standpoint, human bipedal locomotion freed up our forelimbs/arms such that "limb assisted pointing" became possible/practical. Perhaps why elephants seem to grasp human pointing is because their trunks serve as a similarly "free" limb that they can use to point at things. Sort of like convergent evolution, but behavioral rather than morphological... > "When they detect something alarming, they characteristically face towards it and raise their trunk above their head with the tip of the trunk pointed to [the danger]," Byrne said. "We've always thought they were sniffing the breeze, but maybe they're also pointing; our results suggest that's more than possible." https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/131010-elephant-pointing-animals-behavior-africa-science https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/131010-el...
- aschearer 4y agoYour post is a perfect demonstration of what Frans de Waal gets at in "Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Are?"
- manv1 4y agoMany dogs will look at what you're pointing at and not your finger. It depends on the dog. And there are dogs that are literally bred to point...but they're usually pointing at game. There are dogs that will literally drag you to what they're trying to show you. And many (most?) dogs will bring you a toy to you that they want you to play with. I've never actually seen a cat do that, but I presume there must be a few.
- manv1 4y agoDogs can also tell you're pointing with your attention, if they're paying attention.
- helf 4y agoJust a side note: I have two carts and one of them rarely follows where I am pointing. The other one aways does. And he seems to recognize a good 100 words. You’ll get massively varying levels of “intelligence” from most anything it seems