4 ms·
I absolutely consider every government elected with a minority of the votes under FPTP to have been illegitimate and undemocratic. A government formed through
by vidarh 4y ago
I absolutely consider every government elected with a minority of the votes under FPTP to have been illegitimate and undemocratic.
A government formed through negotiation is more democratic if you accept that a representative government can ever be democratic and that the parties actually represents the interests of their voters in as much as if neither party achieves a majority, then a compromise that provides for some of what is wanted by all is more democratic. If anything, I'd argue the broader coalition the more democratic - democracies are best measured by how well they ensure also the interests of the minorities are protected.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> every government elected with a minority of the votes under FPTP ... illegitimate and undemocratic The social contract isn't to be "only be ruled by a strict majority" but to agree to be ruled by the party who wins by any workable system.
- vidarh 4y agoA contract implies a meeting of minds. I do not accept any system which has systematically denied me representation my entire adult life as legitimate in any way. A system imposed on people which denies them representation has no claim to be considered democratic.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoAll representative systems are somewhat undemocratic but the point of them is to pick someone who's we can agree is legitimately the winner of the contest - not to deadlock trying to pick a winner to a better standard. The primary goal isn't to represent, but to reduce misrepresentation to the point where we can literally live with it. To me it's only illegitimate if this is coupled with unreasonable attempts to keep us from improving the system as technology and knowledge give us the means.