3 ms·
> Municipal broadband, power, roads, schools, post, housing, and healthcare? It's long overdue, and with an appropriate amount of funding has been shown to be e
by rayiner 4y ago
> Municipal broadband, power, roads, schools, post, housing, and healthcare? It's long overdue, and with an appropriate amount of funding has been shown to be effective at controlling costs and delivering moderately good quality in most cases.
Where? The US has among the highest percentage of kids going to government owned and operated schools. We have plenty of government housing as well (projects). Nearly all of our roads and transit systems are publicly owned and operated too.
Almost uniformly, those government operated systems aren’t very good—in America. And it doesn’t have to do with “funding.” If you compare with Europe, we spend more money per student, per transit rider, and per public housing resident, etc.
- miguelazo 4y agoThere are many causes of lackluster public education, and funding is definitely one of them. Another huge one is the ability of parents who have the time and resources to divert their children (likely already at a huge advantage) to private and charter schools, thereby skewing the public school below the median in a vicious circle. I’ve seen this exact dynamic play out in many of the cities I have lived. It’s also why newer suburbs (avoiding legacy costs and filled with upwardly mobile, resourced families) have excellent public schools.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoIt's difficult to overstate just how huge selection bias can get in the education space. I went to a high school in the Bay Area, one of a handful in my city. (1) Houses in our attendance area were ~$500,000+x more expensive than ones right across the street in another attendance area, because our school was "better". Why was it better? Because the parents paying an extra half million dollars to get their kid into a better school were going to make sure their kid did better, come hell or high water. So there were lots and lots and lots of after-school tutoring centers, where students would get taught the highschool material in advance, so that they would already know it forward and back when they were tested on it. Which makes the school test well, and thus look better than the other schools in the area, raising housing prices. x += $100,000; GOTO (1). The actual quality of the education was substandard, but there is something to be said for being embedded in an environment where academic failure was simply not considered an option.
- rayiner 4y ago> There are many causes of lackluster public education, and funding is definitely one of them Explain why some of the worst school systems are some of the best funded. https://foxbaltimore.com/news/project-baltimore/more-than-75-percent-test-elementary-level-math-reading-baltimore-city-high-school https://foxbaltimore.com/news/project-baltimore/more-than-75... https://foxbaltimore.com/news/project-baltimore/baltimore-city-schools-spending-per-student-2022-enrollment-performance-kirwan-new-york-boston-washington https://foxbaltimore.com/news/project-baltimore/baltimore-ci...
- miguelazo 4y agoThe increase mentioned in your article was in the last 4 years? Seems a bit late for the testing outcomes in your original link. Pretty terrible example. Also, that area is a perfect example of where parents with the means move their kids (and their attention) to charter/private operations, exacerbating the problem.
- arcticbull 4y agoIts easy to point at what doesn't work well, there's tons and tons of things that work great that nobody talks about. Municipal broadband: the best broadband in the entire United States is provided by the municipality of Chattanooga. [1] Post: The USPS is the most trusted brand in the United States, above FedEx and UPS. [2] Transit: The New York City Subway is the 3rd largest metro rail system on earth after London and Guangzhou. Ok fine, it's expensive to build - but it moved 1,300,000,000 people in 2021. That's just three random ones. [1] https://www.ama.org/marketing-news/usps-ranked-most-trusted-brand-in-u-s/ https://www.ama.org/marketing-news/usps-ranked-most-trusted-... [2] https://qz.com/1996234/the-best-broadband-in-the-us-is-in-chattanooga-tn https://qz.com/1996234/the-best-broadband-in-the-us-is-in-ch...
- vluft 4y ago> Municipal broadband: the best broadband in the entire United States is provided by the municipality of Chattanooga. You can even get 25G from EPB now, though the 10G is good enough for me, frankly. That being said, there's several locations in the US where 10G residential fiber is broadly available; frequently either municipal or co-op (e.g. Utopia Fiber in Utah), though I believe EPB was first in 2015.
- kmeisthax 4y agoAmerican schooling sucks because it's beholden to political objectives contrary to the interests of educating children. Look at the manufactured controversy over "intelligent design" a few decades back, or the current controversies over transgender bathroom access, or Florida's censorship of material in school libraries[0]. Municipal broadband and the post works well because the US is good at building infrastructure. But at the same time, our government is also beholden to interests that want to kill that infrastructure so they can sell costlier and worse equivalents. States passed a bunch of laws to ban local government from running ISPs and Congress has been putting stupid funding mandates on the USPS's pension schemes that make a profitable public venture unprofitable. Transit is a bad example because America is famously addicted to cars and allergic to any transit system that isn't a road. The NYC Subway could not be built today under the current political climate. Hell, it wasn't even built by the city or state government; it was stolen from the people who built the system through overregulation. Nationally, we have Amtrak[1], which was created by bailing out failing freight companies. With some high-speed upgrades it could be great, but the system is still beholden to those same freight companies' infrastructure[2]. The underlying problem is that America does not want to build working government programs. It is run by people who deliberately take funding in order to burn it so they can complain about how much better "privately-run" monopolized systems are. [0] There are probably examples that right-wingers would point out as well - maybe check Reason or CATO for them, because I forgot. [1] US citizen: Japan has high-speed bullet trains! We should build a Shinkansen! US: We have a Shinkansen at home. Shinkansen at home: [2] Which, BTW, is actually supposed to give Amtrak priority over the rails. Like it says it in the actual law. Nobody cares.