4 ms·
The current government is of a party that has a majority in parliament despite getting a minority of the votes. It's fairly reasonable to consider the UK undemo
by vidarh 4y ago
The current government is of a party that has a majority in parliament despite getting a minority of the votes. It's fairly reasonable to consider the UK undemocratic and unaccountable, even if there are far worse alternatives.
- kmlx 4y ago> The current government is of a party that has a majority in parliament despite getting a minority of the votes. if you don’t know how the UK system works, then yes, you are correct.
- vidarh 4y agoIt's knowing full well how the UK system works for many decades, and living here for a couple of decades and observing the largescale disenfranchisement of UK voters which has made me firmly hold that opinion.
- easytiger 4y agoDescribe examples of this "disenfranchisement" please.
- developer93 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-past-the-post_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-past-the-post_voting Parties can and do win despite most people voting against them if those against them don't vote for the same party. Other voting systems don't have this problem, but allow voters to be represented in the proportions in which they vote.
- kmlx 4y ago> allow voters to be represented in the proportions in which they vote. lived most of my life in such a system. it basically disenfranchised people from voting as whatever party they voted for never got enough votes and had to go into an alliance with other parties thus dropping their election pledges and thus removing any sort of democratic mandate. result: fewer and fewer people now go out to vote: https://www.statista.com/statistics/300427/eu-parlament-turnout-for-the-european-elections/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/300427/eu-parlament-turn...
- vidarh 4y agoUnder FPTP a large proportion of voters lose effective representation, while in a proportional system you are able to vote for parties who will negotiate the way you want them to. I grew up on Norway, where parties always would go into elections with promises about what their negotiation goals for a coalition would be, because people understood that enfranchising as many as possible means negotiated compromises, not letting on faction push through whatever they want. Democracies are best judged by how well they ensure minorities interests are allowed to influence policy.
- kmlx 4y ago> negotiated compromises exactly this is why voters simply don't turn up to vote any more. by "negotiating" those parties break their election pledges to their voters. voters thus become disenfranchised. we can see the end result today: very few people vote. > Democracies are best judged by how well they ensure minorities interests are allowed to influence policy. there are many ways to judge democracies. that's just one of the myriad of indicators.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kmlx 4y ago> observing the largescale disenfranchisement of UK voters i think you’re confusing democracy in general (and it’s many flaws) with whatever you’ve noticed in the UK. if you’d study other democratic countries you’d find huge issues as well.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Veen 4y agoWhat does a 'minority of the votes' mean? In the 2019 general election, the conservatives got 13,966,000 votes and the next largest party got 10,269,000.
- vidarh 4y agoThe Tories got 43.6% of the votes. So a minority of the votes cast gave them a substantial majority of the seats in parliament. Only the fundamentally undemocratic electoral system gave them the ability to form a government without negotiating a coalition.
- Veen 4y agoI understand that some people don't agree with First Past the Post systems, but it's a little overblown to say it's fundamentally undemocratic. And I don't see how a coalition government formed through horse trading and favor-swapping in backroom negotiations is more democratic. (Somewhat related: Anyone who complains about the 'undemocratically elected' Tories is compelled by consistency to complain about the 'undemocratically elected' Labour government of Tony Blair and the likely forthcoming 'undemocratic' government of Kier Starmer. If they are quiet about that, then they haven't a leg to stand on. See also complaining about the results of the Brexit Referendum, which won a clear, although narrow, majority of the people who bothered to vote, and was therefore legitimate by the lights of people who prefer majority decisions.)
- vidarh 4y agoI absolutely consider every government elected with a minority of the votes under FPTP to have been illegitimate and undemocratic. A government formed through negotiation is more democratic if you accept that a representative government can ever be democratic and that the parties actually represents the interests of their voters in as much as if neither party achieves a majority, then a compromise that provides for some of what is wanted by all is more democratic. If anything, I'd argue the broader coalition the more democratic - democracies are best measured by how well they ensure also the interests of the minorities are protected.