3 ms·
How many traffickers selling overpriced dinghy rides across the Channel advertise within the UK, where the UK law can actually reach? No, that amendment was cl
by ben_w 4y ago
How many traffickers selling overpriced dinghy rides across the Channel advertise within the UK, where the UK law can actually reach?
No, that amendment was clearly intended to prevent lefty liberals like me from saying that the asylum seekers themselves are in any way decent or good or deserving of support.
Same party used similar language for a thing called "Section 28", so they don't get to pretend they don't know what effect it would have.
- Veen 4y agoThat's not true at all. The Online Safety Bill simply designates as a priority content that breaks an existing prohibition against aiding, abetting, counselling, and conspiring to carry out offenses under the Immigration Act 1971. Lefty open-borders types can continue to say what they like. The connection to section 28 is spurious and deserves no rebuttal. The two things have nothing to do with each other.
- flir 4y ago> an existing prohibition against aiding, abetting, counselling, and conspiring to carry out offenses under the Immigration Act 1971 I could believe that's a thing (although I'd appreciate a reference if you've got it). I couldn't, however, believe "posting videos of people crossing the channel that show that activity in a positive light" counts as any of those things.
- Veen 4y ago> We will also add section 24 of the Immigration Act 1971 to the priority offences list in schedule 7. Although the offences in section 24 cannot be carried out online, paragraph 33 of the schedule states that priority illegal content includes the inchoate offences relating to the offences that are listed. Therefore, aiding, abetting, counselling, conspiring etc. those offences by posting videos of people crossing the channel that show that activity in a positive light could be an offence that is committed online and therefore falls within what is priority illegal content. The result of this amendment would therefore be that platforms would have to proactively remove that content. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2023-01-17/debates/23011748000005/OnlineSafetyBill https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2023-01-17/debates/230...
- flir 4y agoMany thanks. It's actually section 25. That confused me for a bit. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1971/77/section/25 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1971/77/section/25 I don't see how anyone can get from what's written there to "aiding, abetting, counselling, conspiring etc. those offences by posting videos of people crossing the channel that show that activity in a positive light". It just says "facilitates". But I know nothing about law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> the asylum seekers themselves are in any way decent or good or deserving of support I think the many generally feel the same way about refugees but just that a lot of the people arriving are not validly refugees. People boating out of France to the UK are, by international definition, not refugees. They've already escaped persecution in their home countries. My parents jumped a border while emigrating to avoid a war so I empathize but I wish we could discuss the topic without emotionally loading it by calling people asylum seekers when they are not or implying that others don't care about people in general. There are resource and fairness issues that emotional appeals won't make go away.
- ben_w 4y ago> People boating out of France to the UK are, by international definition, not refugees. Which international law do you think does that? (I'm assuming from your username that you're a lawyer; I'm not, though I do try to read the texts of statutes sometimes). I remember hearing a lot about the Dublin Regulation, but that's an EU rule that no longer applies because of Brexit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dublin_Regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dublin_Regulation (I tried reading the legal text for this even though the UK is no longer in it, but a casual skim didn't get me anything that did what it's usually claimed as doing, the claim being that it requires asylum seekers to claim in the first safe country). > There are resource and fairness issues that emotional appeals won't make go away. This particular point I vehemently disagree with. The resource and fairness issues with regard to these people is, IMO, caused by their demonisation in the public eye and as such will be fixed by emotional appeal. This is because their status legal status means they are by default actively prevented from working and covering their own costs, and this only has some limited exceptions: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/handling-applications-for-permission-to-take-employment-instruction/permission-to-work-and-volunteering-for-asylum-seekers-accessible https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/handling-applicat...
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> > by international definition, not refugees. > Which international law do you think does that? I used the term 'international definition' intentionally. I'm speaking about the common definition of the word not including people in the situation of crossing multiple large friendly countries to go to another as refugees at that point. The immediate threat to life and limb is over and now others are in more dire need. And yet, it's not as simple as entry to the first country either, because we can both acknowledge that if someone escaping from Syria crosses the border into Iraq or Lebanon that they should keep on walking until they find an actually safe place. But the point is that you're talking to people, using emotional terms, but trying to use legalistic reasoning to make them do something they feel is not only needed but benefits the wrong people. They're using their eyes and judging the conditions of the refugee claimants and finding them wanting. > > emotional appeals won't make go away. > caused by their demonisation in the public eye and as such will be fixed by emotional appeal. I have a feeling that this has already been tried and that there's probably some misalignment preventing that from working - maybe making it backfire. Maybe that you may feel that this isn't a valid political opinion on the values of the refugee system but a comment on the race of the claimants or something...? Thankfully in my country many of the questionable refugee claimants are the same racial group as many current legal immigrants and this is defusing that would otherwise be a nasty race-baiting angle to the debate. Otherwise, I would ask what more demonization you think is needed other than for them to be shown to be jumping a queue meant to save lives? > their status legal status means they are by default actively prevented from working and covering their own costs If they really are fleeing for their life we can cover the costs and would be glad to.