4 ms·
When Galileo "discovered" that the Earth revolves around the sun, rather than everything revolves around the Earth - it was not just him against the Church, as
by somenameforme 4y ago
When Galileo "discovered" that the Earth revolves around the sun, rather than everything revolves around the Earth - it was not just him against the Church, as is often framed. It was him against the entirety of scientific knowledge and other scientists of the day. And he didn't really have any precise proof. In fact his ideas were mostly wrong. He made a large number of incorrect assumptions (such as requiring perfectly spherical orbits) that resulted in his entire concept having more holes than swiss cheese. And it was easily picked apart by other scientists of the time, which many readily did.
He had utter disrespect for the science of the times, and held his own hamstringed ideas above all. Yet he was able to express them. And eventually he would get to play his small part in the advancement of the knowledge of humanity. And this is precisely how science operates. In science one does not HAVE to do anything. Had Galileo instead been determined that e.g. Jupiter is the center of the universe, and spent an equally feverish amount of energy trying to demonstrate such, then we wouldn't know his name today - but his work and ideas would have been no less scientific - but merely wrong.
- brookst 4y agoAll true and well said. But my crazy aunt repeating falsehoods she read on Facebook is most certainly not sciencing even up to the imperfect standards of Galileo. Just because some legit scientists were dismissed as quacks does not make every quack a scientist.
- mrguyorama 4y ago>it was not just him against the Church, as is often framed. It was him against the entirety of scientific knowledge and other scientists of the day It really really wasn't. There were already models of the solar system that had the sun as the central element. Often they just weren't as good at predicting the movement of the stars because the prevailing mathematical models were very overfitted to the (bad) data, so it always looked closer. Really it had just been refined very well. Some things to keep in mind: The scientific method didn't exist, the idea of representing the world as mathematical models to predict things and understand physics was barely there, and the primary purpose of the mathematical models of the solar system was to make astrology better. Nobody really cared about whether the world was helio or geo centric, because the idea of deferring to mathematical models was not considered the gold standard we have today.
- ted_dunning 4y agoAre you thinking of Copernicus, perhaps?