3 ms·
The majority of popular science content defers to expert opinion because most people do not want to trudge through heaps of scientific detail and dry statistica
by anigbrowl 4y ago
The majority of popular science content defers to expert opinion because most people do not want to trudge through heaps of scientific detail and dry statistical language. You might be falling into the trap of projecting your own interest in science and technology onto the population at large.
Because the pandemic pushed a lot of people toward videoconference etc, hardcore medical knowledge is actually more accessible than ever before. People who were really, truly interested in what medical scientists and public health experts thought about COVID-19 could go to youtube channels like the UCSF grand rounds and get the straight dope from doctors at the leading edge of policy and research, talking to an audience of other doctors and getting down into the weeds of cellular biology, DNA base pairs, and statistical significance.
I've never seen any of the 'do your own research' crowds cite any of this work. When they cite something, it's wrapped in 17 layers of confirmation bias. If you complain about fallacies from people who are generally trying to simplify things for an audience that demands simple explanations, and then ignore that fallacious arguments coming from their intellectual or ideological opponents, are you wandering off into fallacy yourself?
- motohagiography 4y agoArguments that reduce to labeling something as a conspiracy theory are destructive to truth seeking and an adulteration of discourse - but they are consistent with the fear of criticism that they are intened to target and leverage. We can't launder poor arguments through complexity/uncertainty boxes like the USC grand rounds videos and say, "well, unless you understand this granular level, you can't disagree with this lateral and aggregate policy one." I wonder if on a basic level the people who argue like that aren't engaged in discovering truth, but actuated by merely avoiding criticism and seeking to align to something symbolic that protects them. This may be the crux of the disagreement. If I have an ideological position, it is that I believe my opposing team is engaged in the neutralization of discourse because for them to prevail in their power struggles they only need for principled people to do nothing. This is perhaps the divide. There are people aligned to an ideal of truth that originates in religious cultural beliefs, and people aligned to a fear of criticism that originates in a more materialist ideology. This scope shift from an "appeal to authority" to reframing it as a "deference to authority," in the counter argument doesn't counter my original point, which was that scientists may feel they are under seige because they have been exploited in appeals to authority, and feel blowback from some people who understood that ploy and rejected it. They are orthogonal concepts. Sure, media defers to experts, they tell stories that include them, but the variations like "this is true because authority says so", "authority said: do this or become a hate figure," and "you are suffering because of these non-believers, just ask these authorities" were disingenuous rhetorical devices employed by media and policymakers with no objection from actual scientists. Maybe these scientists would feel less threatened if they had less fear of criticism and more intellectual courage.
- tptacek 4y agoNot only that, but the people who do want to trudge through heaps of scientific detail are often "motivated reasoners" who don't really have backgrounds in the field or know how to qualify a research report, as we saw with the ivermectin fiasco, which included some very credible-looking meta sources that were very clearly treating obvious garbage research reports as important data points that they could aggregate with others.
- mrguyorama 4y agoRemember, half of america can't even read at a highschool level. How can they possibly expect to actually understand a research paper, and have the knowledge in statistics and probability to see when a paper has massaged the conclusion. I've taken stats and probability and I still don't feel like I have a strong enough grasp on stats to properly judge papers. How the hell is steve the plumber supposed to be able to independently interpret research papers that require a stats understanding, some calc, some background knowledge in chemistry etc, to actually understand? These papers are written by people who have been steeped in extremely tiny segments of their field for a decade. A layman cannot understand that.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 4y agoNone of this has anything to do with what I said.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoExcept it does. You can’t ask the avg Joe to trust if you abuse that trust with policy decisions that just happen to benefit a political ideology.