4 ms·
>Whom do you choose? The guy who performs better. >I argue that you should choose the student which is more likely to make the most out of those resources. ..
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>Whom do you choose?
The guy who performs better.
>I argue that you should choose the student which is more likely to make the most out of those resources. ... the difference in GPA compared to students in the same cohort?
The entire point of equality is that we are all one cohort: Regardless your race, gender, background, or creed you will be treated the same as the next guy in line; and there is only one line.
To treat otherwise is discrimination.
- gadders 4y agoIt totally is discrimination, but it's discrimination based on facts. What we have now is even if the first student is from an ethnic minority, and the second is from an ethnic majority, the ethnic minority student would be preferred.
- cuteboy19 4y agoUnless you're asian in which case the white student would be preferred
- andrepd 4y ago> The guy who performs better. Did you read what I wrote? > The entire point of equality is that we are all one cohort Well but we aren't. One of the strongest predictors of academic performance is parental income. Burying your head in the sand and pretending the problem doesn't exist is not a satisfactory answer.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>Did you read what I wrote? I did. If you aren't rewarding effort, skill, and talent there is no incentive to be successful. You pick the 3.8 GPA, aka the guy who performs better. >Well but we aren't. One of the strongest predictors of academic performance is parental income. Burying your head in the sand and pretending the problem doesn't exist is not a satisfactory answer. If the objective is to further equality, then the answer is to treat everyone the same with no arbitrary separators because that is the entire point of equality. With regards to university admissions, the performance measure in question is one's GPA or whatever objective measure the university wants to use. Income brackets can become a consideration if we are discussing financial assistance programs, but that is tangent to admission. Any program that favors people of a certain race or gender, either minority or otherwise, is literally racist and/or sexist and should not be tolerated.