3 ms·
It's a good question, and I honestly think that SimTable has struggled with that. From a playing perspective, or educational perspective, the sand is great. Wh
by SamBam 4y ago
It's a good question, and I honestly think that SimTable has struggled with that.
From a playing perspective, or educational perspective, the sand is great. What happens with wildfires if we make the mountain this big? What happens to the water table if erosion cuts a valley through here? The immediate feedback that you can get by just shaping the landscape differently with your hands is really cool.
From a wildfire training perspective, or other disaster management, it's different because you're dealing with an existing landscape. I've seen them start by projecting a map, then forming the sand with their hands to match the map, and then starting the simulation. But at that point is the 3D landscape needed? You could also project onto a flat table.
I guess the reason is that it helps the fire chiefs or whoever really envision the landscape. "Ah, yes, this is Devil's Pass, I see how the wind is going to blow right through there and blow the fire that way. What if we cut a fire lane here? Ok, that slows it down."
But it could also be a cool technology being used as a solution to a non-problem.
- generalizations 4y ago> I guess the reason is that it helps the fire chiefs or whoever really envision the landscape. "Ah, yes, this is Devil's Pass, I see how the wind is going to blow right through there and blow the fire that way. What if we cut a fire lane here? Ok, that slows it down." Yeah, if you're familiar with topographical maps (the way any decent hiker or fire chief would be), you really don't need the physical 3d layout to envision the landscape.
- noduerme 4y agoah yeah, I was just thinking about that firefighter demo and couldn't understand how the topography was correlated with the surface. (It seems like it'd be super cool if you could scoop out lakes and stuff... I've never seen or played with something like that.) The tactile aspect of the sand is neat. I can see it as a good learning tool as you described for thinking about wind patterns and road cuts.