4 ms·
Something I've been wondering about with regard to CBDCs; if you're in a Western country with low inflation and good banks there seems like little point. But wh
by pjc50 4y ago
Something I've been wondering about with regard to CBDCs; if you're in a Western country with low inflation and good banks there seems like little point. But what if it were an explicit goal to make a CBDC usable in other countries? Export US price stability to Argentina.
- rchaud 4y ago> if you're in a Western country with low inflation and good banks there seems like little point. Not at all. Some EU countries aside, most western countries do not have a good inter-bank payment system and are still dependent on Mastercard, Visa and Paypal to handle merchant transaction settlements. Local currency cash is the only thing a state has control over. As use of cash declines, it becomes important to have a centrally-administered digital cash alternative, just like paper cash.
- dmurray 4y ago> Local currency cash is the only thing a state has control over. The state has control over its banks. You can't generally get a Mastercard or Visa card that isn't issued by a bank doing business in your jurisdiction. How tightly the state holds the reins of the bank depends, but usually they're among the most regulated of the nominally private institutions we have.
- rchaud 4y agoCash usually doesn't carry any fees, whereas electronic transactions incur large enough fees to make small transactions burdensome for small businesses. Payments are an important enough area IMO for countries to implement interoperable standards, rather than wait for the private sector, all competing among themselves, to offer one.
- gus_massa 4y agoIt's call "Dollarization". We called it "Convertibility". In Brazil it was the "Real Plan". It has tried in many other countries. Each one is slightly different, so if you have a lot of popcorn you can try to read each one and understand the differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution The main problem is that the government has a deficit of 5%. All the solutions to fix the deficit are unpopular, so they prefer to keep emitting money. (Now they are trying a few unpopular fixes, but not too much, just to keep the inflation not too high.) If you switch to 100% external currency, after a few month the government will have no money. They can pay you a part of the salary of $1000 with the external currency, after a few months they will have to pay $900 in external currency and $100 in IOU. Later pay $800 in external currency and $200 in IOU. ... [1] The problem is that people will be unhappy with the increase of IOU. So it's easier to pay the full $1000 in IOU, and ensure that you can exchange the $1000 IOU to $1000 in external currency. OK, now it's $999 of external currency. Never mind, $998. What about $997? ... [1] Actually, we tried something like it too! In the 1990 each province had a local money and they paid the local employees a part in the national money and a part in the local money, or perhaps all in the local money. Initially it was fine, but after some months you got a haircut of 30% if you need to send money to another province or buy fuel or some other items not produced localy.