4 ms·
If Microsoft made their own hardware, this comparison might be more apt. Nobody's complaining you can't run Linux on 360 out of the box.
by astrodust 15y ago
If Microsoft made their own hardware, this comparison might be more apt. Nobody's complaining you can't run Linux on 360 out of the box.
- wlesieutre 15y agoThough they are making that complaint about the PS3, because you used to be able to
- CrLf 15y agoRight, you used to be able to. Some people bought their PS3's over the competition because it could run Linux. Then comes a firmware update and that feature is gone. Sorry about that.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- molmalo 15y agoActually, I remember back in 2009 when there was an outcry because Microsoft launched an update wich could stop users from installing Linux on their Xbox 360 [1]. So, your comment does not apply to Microsoft. They can make their own hardware, buy they will still be criticized, basically, just because they are Microsoft. [1] http://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-378090.html http://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-378090.html
- jimbobimbo 15y agoThis is not a good argument: you cannot buy a tablet without operating system and install something later - you buy the package of tablet hardware with operating system. How I see what Microsoft does now, they simply say to vendors: if you want to sell your hardware with our system, these are our requirements. Given that vendor can sell same tablet with, say, Android, what's the problem here? They won't be allowed to put Windows logo on the tablet, but I guess it's not a big deal. Another thing that bothers me in this media noise about "Linux lockout": vendors are locking down their tablets and phones right now, without any Microsoft help - where's the public outcry?
- nitrogen 15y agovendors are locking down their tablets and phones right now, without any Microsoft help - where's the public outcry? There's a difference between a hardware manufacturer voluntarily choosing to lock down its own hardware (which is bad), and an independent operating system vendor forcing hardware manufacturers to lock down their hardware (which is anticompetitive). Besides, there's plenty of outcry about locked-down phones and tablets, which is why HTC announced that they are no longer locking the bootloader on their devices.
- jimbobimbo 15y agoLook, Microsoft does not prohibit Samsung selling their Galaxy Tab with whatever Samsung wants to ship. They prohibit Samsung selling their Galaxy Tab with Windows 8 ARM pre-installed on it. This - tablet AND Windows 8 - is a ONE product, hence you cannot divide h/w vendor and OS vendor. This is as simple as that. Samsung is free to not to ship tablets with Windows 8 ARM - how is that anti-competitive? ARM devices are not supposed to be fiddled with by customers in their current state, PCs are. This business model is a status quo right now, like it or not, and Microsoft plays by the rules. The game is different in PCs and Microsoft has a different position on lockdown there.
- nitrogen 15y agoThere are two critical differences between Microsoft's lockdown and the status quo of the ARM tablet market: 1. The status quo in the tablet market is for hardware manufacturers to decide whether to lock down their boot loader. Microsoft (who is not a hardware manufacturer) would force hardware manufacturers to lock the boot loader of any ARM devices running Windows 8. 2. Not all ARM devices are tablets and phones. ARM-based netbooks (i.e. miniature general-purpose PCs) have been available for a long time, and there's an expectation that you can install whatever OS you want on a general-purpose PC. Microsoft's ARM lockdown rules (as quoted on the previous HN discussion of the subject) would apply to devices that people expect to be able to customize.
- deleted 15y ago