4 ms·
Maybe "Where do you live?" should be one of those questions employers shouldn't be allowed to ask? Like what's your religion or what's your sexual orientation?
by scotty79 4y ago
Maybe "Where do you live?" should be one of those questions employers shouldn't be allowed to ask? Like what's your religion or what's your sexual orientation?
- sokoloff 4y agoSo long as there are governments involved in the employee-employer relationship, this can’t happen. I don’t actually care where you live, but I do care that I can legally employ you, pay you, pay taxes/social charges, and that I understand the obligations of the arrangement we’re contemplating entering.
- scotty79 4y agoIt could be set up completely differently. Employer could pay 100% to the government and government could pay employee after properly taxing the income. But that would require work from the government that it doesn't want to do.
- sokoloff 4y agoWhich government(s)? Taxes and social charges can vary by city, county, state, and country. If I'm going to hire scotty79 with no knowledge of where in the world they live, which governments would I coordinate with and how would I know that? Employment rules, customs, and laws vary by at least state and country (and minimum wages vary by city). How would I know what laws applied to the employment relationship?
- scotty79 4y agoFederal obviously. Somebody has to know what's up with all this mess. If I'm from another country government should know that and tax accordingly. I have no idea how placing burden of knowing all this on every single employer helps anybody (except IRS).
- ghaff 4y agoIn fact, it's much more at the state level. I owe the IRS the same no matter where I live in the US (leaving aside deductions for state and local taxes). But I need state residency for my driver's license and state taxes. The IRS doesn't care if I live in Nevada or California. But California certainly cares if I claim to live in Nevada and actually live in California for 8 months out of the year.
- scotty79 4y agoGreat so Califonia has business in knowing if some worker lives in California. So they should be the one to ask. Employer doesn't have to know. Do you report and pay federal taxes and state taxes separately? Or do you just deal with IRS and they forward the docs and the money to the state you live in?
- ghaff 4y ago>Do you report and pay federal taxes and state taxes separately? Yes. They are separate sets of forms that you pay (or get refunded) independently. They're basically unrelated exxcept to the degree that deductions/refunds may come into play. The employer is making various deductions and payments, e.g. into unemployment, based on the state you live in. So your employer really does need to know your state of residence.
- scotty79 4y agoWow. That's horrible. You should get this sorted out first at country level.
- paulcole 4y agoThis just wouldn’t work in the US. The regulations vary greatly from state to state and even city to city. Choosing to employ a person in a state for the first time can be a very costly decision (in both time and $$$) for a small business. The second, third, fourth, etc. employees are marginally less expensive but “breaking the seal” and hiring that first employee in a new state isn’t something that every business takes lightly.
- scotty79 4y agoThe question is, should it be like that? Shouldn't government handle the legal differences between states so that employers don't have to deal with that?
- ghaff 4y agoNo. Because the system of government in the US is such that states have the responsibility for lots of things rather than the federal government. However, that has the side effect of making the state you live in actually matter. I can't (or am at least not supposed to) just establish an address of convenience somewhere that has the lowest taxes.
- sokoloff 4y agoIf you're going to have a republic of states, those states are going to be able to have different laws. The minimum wage in New Hampshire is $7.25/hr, while it's $15/hr in neighboring Massachusetts. If I'm an employer in New Hampshire hiring remote workers for $12/hr, that's legal if they work in NH, but not legal if they work in MA. NH has sovereignty to set their minimum wage (subject to the limit of the federal minimum wage). They might do that to attract business there. Massachusetts has the same sovereignty to set their minimum wage. Which state should give up their sovereignty so that an employer [possibly out of state] could practically hire people without knowing where they live?
- scotty79 4y agoNone. But the state or even preferably the country should take responsibility for establishing where employee lives and taxing the salary accordingly.