4 ms·
In the same way that seatbelts don't stop deaths from motor vehicle accidents but do significantly reduce them, vaccines don't stop transmission but they do sig
by defrost 4y ago
In the same way that seatbelts don't stop deaths from motor vehicle accidents but do significantly reduce them, vaccines don't stop transmission but they do significantly reduce the transmission rates.
Similar statistical model as control rods in a nuclear reactor - they don't stop neutrons, they significantly reduce the numbe of free neutrons flying about and avoid an exponential increase and runaway chain reaction.
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoAccording to the cdc: > Seat belts reduce serious crash-related injuries and deaths by about half Do you have some evidence that the vaccines are in that ballpark against infection/transmission in 2023?
- benjaminwootton 4y agoIn the highly unlikely case that they did reduce transmission by 50%, people would still catch the same mild disease, it would just slow transmission. So that argument has a time limit which is way less than the 3 years we’ve been playing this game. And even if it was 99% effective, it certainly doesn’t justify leaving drugs in the market where one mutation potentially has humanity ending consequences. The Covid vaccine was great for helping the elderley and vulnerable from day one. For the rest of us, it was a busted flush.
- busymom0 4y agoNo they do not reduce transmission. That was clear when delta hit, they found same viral loads in vaxxed and unvaxxed even if mild symptoms. And a vax which merely reduced symptoms gives a false sense of safety where they end up becoming silent spreaders of the virus. This happened here in Ontario where during delta, an over 50s hockey league had an outbreak where 15 fully vaxxed got infected, 1 elderly died and then their family wondered how this happened. Similar thing happened in Manitoba where 80% of an elderly long term care facility got infected despite everyone being fully vaxxed. Comparing a seat belt to a permanent medical procedure inside the body is asinine. Seat belts don’t go inside the body, can be taken off, don’t need a new belt on top of old one every few months, get recalled if defective, manufacturer can be sued, belts don’t cause blood clot or heart inflammation.
- brookst 4y agoDo you also oppose the polio vaccine because it merely reduces the odds of infection? And every other vaccine for the same reason? There is not a vaccine in the world that provides 100% protection to every individual. ALL vaccines work by reducing R0 to <1 so outbreaks shrink rather than growing. I can’t believe we’re still doing the nutty antivax thing in 2023.
- eldenwrong 4y agoUh most vaccines did offer pretty good immunity and an extreme reduction in transmission They are not in the same category at all
- nostromo 4y agoTwo things can be true… Vaccines are typically very effective. So effective they can eliminate a virus among vaccinated populations. Covid-19 vaccines are sorta effective. They didn’t eliminate virus transmission among vaccinated populations. But they reduced the severity of cases. Pretending the vaccines weren’t underwhelming in terms of efficacy doesn’t do us any favors, because people know from their own experience that most vaccinated people have had Covid.
- defrost 4y agoPolio vaccine didn't eliminate transmission either. As I stated above the COVID vaccines didn't eliminate transmission they reduced transmission rates. I've just replied to another comment and provided two (of many) statistically significant studies (for professional epidemiologists) that confirm that (specifically for two vaccines in the UK). There are other studies across the globe that affirm the same conclusion. The important truths about "people know from their own experience that most vaccinated people have had Covid." are that many vaccinated people had COVID .. a milder form with greatly reduced rates of hospitalisation, reduced rates of critical care, and reduced rates of death.
- busymom0 4y ago