11 ms·
Microsoft mandating Secure Boot on ARM, making Linux installs difficult
- brudgers 15y agoPrevious discussion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- wavephorm 15y agoSigh. So why doesn't the Linux community just man-up, and start backing Linux-oriented hardware manufacturers? This pansy whiny attitude from the Linux community got tiresome 10 years ago. Today, it's just absurd. Please just quit whining, and quit trying to "make Microsoft our bitch", and start supporting hardware companies that are already on your side, and completely ignore Microsoft and hardware companies that bow to them.
- wmf 15y agoIf they try and fail, they'll have no one to blame but themselves; if they don't try then they can keep shifting the blame. I suspect that Shuttleworth is aware of Kay's wisdom about building your own hardware, but the market is probably not there.
- marshray 15y agoBecause economies of scale mean that commodity hardware is vastly less expensive and more available than special-purpose hardware. The number of people who set out to run specifically Linux on a tablet is vanishingly small. I say this as one of them.
- astrodust 15y agoThe commodity components used to assemble a tablet are vastly less expensive than they would be if not used by so many other manufacturers. Where's the Raspberry Pi of tablets?
- wmf 15y agoThere are a ton of craptablets based on Rockchip SoCs. Even so, a craptablet running "real Linux" would probably cost more than the equivalent Android version.
- astrodust 15y agoThe demoscene people do some really amazing work with some very basic hardware, so why can't that kind of talent be applied to making a really ripping Linux tablet?
- recoiledsnake 15y agoMake Apple open up the iPad then. makes sense rather than windows tablets which are barely out.
- kiloaper 15y agoWe don't have to "make" Apple do anything. There are already people porting Linux and Android on their hardware. See http://www.idroidproject.org/wiki/Main_Page http://www.idroidproject.org/wiki/Main_Page
- mcantelon 15y agoWhining about whining: how meta.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 15y ago> So why doesn't the Linux community just man-up, and start backing Linux-oriented hardware manufacturers? We do. The problem is this increases their sales by 1% in notebooks and desktops. There just isn't that many people who want to run Linux on their computers. Microsoft will cleverly induce hardware makers to build those single-purpose locked down tablets to force some market share for a solution they know can't compete on a level playfield. And they'll do so by threatening to increase the exto^H^H^H^Hlicensing fees on patents Android "violates". Watch for those increases after they acquire what's left of Nokia.
- wavephorm 15y agoThere just isn't that many people who want to run Linux on their computers. Yes there is. I know lots of people who run Linux on their desktop. And I bet there's probably even more people that would be interested in a Linux tablet. The argument that Linux is this totally obscure precious little snowflake just doesn't work anymore.
- bitwize 15y agoBut it is totally obscure, and will remain so until it stops sucking on the desktop.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoFor varying definitions of "totally", "obscure" and "sucking". In my opinion, Mac and Windows "suck" compared to my Linux desktop, but I'm not going to assert that as fact.
- wavephorm 15y ago1-2% of a global desktop computing market is small in percentage, but ENORMOUS in total numbers. We're talking about many, many millions of users. And that's just desktop. The potential size of a Linux tablet market is really quite big. But none of that matters if Linux enthusiasts only want to buy a Windows tablet, and reformat it with a free version of Linux that barely works on that hardware.
- skrebbel 15y agoIsn't all this fuzz just Microsoft's history hunting hem? I mean, where's the Ars Technica article about how it's not possible to install Android on an iPhone? So unfair! Nearly all phones and tablets (typically the devices with ARM cpus, which must be Microsoft's reasoning too) only run the OS they came with. Surely phones and tablets with Windows on them aren't the exception.
- astrodust 15y agoIf Microsoft made their own hardware, this comparison might be more apt. Nobody's complaining you can't run Linux on 360 out of the box.
- wlesieutre 15y agoThough they are making that complaint about the PS3, because you used to be able to
- CrLf 15y agoRight, you used to be able to. Some people bought their PS3's over the competition because it could run Linux. Then comes a firmware update and that feature is gone. Sorry about that.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- molmalo 15y agoActually, I remember back in 2009 when there was an outcry because Microsoft launched an update wich could stop users from installing Linux on their Xbox 360 [1]. So, your comment does not apply to Microsoft. They can make their own hardware, buy they will still be criticized, basically, just because they are Microsoft. [1] http://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-378090.html http://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-378090.html
- jimbobimbo 15y agoThis is not a good argument: you cannot buy a tablet without operating system and install something later - you buy the package of tablet hardware with operating system. How I see what Microsoft does now, they simply say to vendors: if you want to sell your hardware with our system, these are our requirements. Given that vendor can sell same tablet with, say, Android, what's the problem here? They won't be allowed to put Windows logo on the tablet, but I guess it's not a big deal. Another thing that bothers me in this media noise about "Linux lockout": vendors are locking down their tablets and phones right now, without any Microsoft help - where's the public outcry?
- sukuriant 15y agoJust a thought with regard to ARM hardware. Don't most Win7 slates on the market have an ARM alternative that runs Android? If that's the case, that means that manufacturers are already providing two different versions of the slates on the market: amd64 and arm; and, that means that manufacturers are already making special modifications just to provide to both markets. Given this information, why would it not be possible, even likely, for manufacturers to continue to do this with Win8 and Android? Have slightly different hardware and sell both. Correct me if I'm wrong, but can't you run a more hardcore linux on an android device? I believe I've seen an original G1 running ubuntu (not a hardcore linux, but moreso than android).
- wmf 15y agoDon't most Win7 slates on the market have an ARM alternative that runs Android? No, because an x86 motherboard is 10x the size of an ARM one, so the internal design needs to be completely different. Win8 and Android... Have slightly different hardware and sell both. This is more likely, so you'd have a choice between locked UEFI and locked U-Boot. Jailbreaking will continue, of course.
- slowpoke 15y agoI think it's besides the point that there are alternatives. Locked down hardware should be universally frowned upon, no matter who is trying to control it - whether that's Microsoft, Apple, or anyone else. It's downright sickening to see this being accepted at all. There are no - I repeat, NO - valid reasons to lock down hardware. It's anti-competitive, it's malicious and most of all it's an affront to Freedom. I also find it quite sad that people (with RMS among them) predicted this years, if not decades ago, and people called them paranoid. We need to fight this. Do not buy locked down hardware. Boycott businesses and corporations pushing this. Tell the hardware suppliers that you will not take this. Use free operating systems and hardware whenever and where-ever at all possible. Pursue other people to do the same. Finally, disregard laws which forbid you to circumvent, render ineffective or deactivate these kinds of restrictions. Spread ways to do this if you can, anonymously. Once information is out there, it cannot be subdued again.
- nodata 15y agoInteresting. I wonder what stopped them mandating this on x86? (Intel cough)
- wmf 15y agoWindows 7, actually. It isn't signed.
- kijin 15y agoAs usual, Microsoft's own products are the most troublesome competitors to its newer products.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoAnd what happens when Windows 9 for ARM comes out and it's signed with a new set of keys that existing locked-down ARM netbooks don't have?
- drivebyacct2 15y agoIt's really disappointing to see the same people commenting here with the same responses as on the original discussion (with the ARM revelation), with the same holes in their logic, just reiterating it, sure that if they repeat themselves they will sound more right. There's more (and better) discussion on the original post: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679