3 ms·
Under several jurisdictions, the depiction of Muhammed is a crime (with extremely harsh punishments). Am I, a citizen of a free country, not allowed to use thi
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Under several jurisdictions, the depiction of Muhammed is a crime (with extremely harsh punishments).
Am I, a citizen of a free country, not allowed to use this app to read a book that has such a depiction? Is this "acceptable"?
Surely if the author lives in such an oppressive country it should be obvious that they don't want me to use the app for this purpose, and I would clearly be in violation of their terms of service, going directly against the open source license and principals.
I don't know who the author is or where they live but the point still stands. And that doesn't even consider the moet vague terms of the sentence.
This looks like one of those "don't pirate books with our app" clauses that's very well-intentioned, but at odds with the open source license attached to the product.
This is what you get when laymen start doing lawyer work, and why copy-pasting legalese is much safer than trying to write your own.
Obviously neither F-Droid nor any of its users are at any risk of violating the ToS, let alone any consequences of doing so. The problem is that you can either allow ToS/license violations or you can't, there's no in-between.
It should also be noted that F-Droid itself may have issues, since the official repository only contains code F-Droid compiles unlike other app stores where you can upload compiled applications.
It's an interesting problem that I'm sure will be solved quickly without too much hassle, but it's also a lesson for open source developers to watch out when it comes to writing terms and conditions.