3 ms·
I fully agree; that was poorly written on my part. I've changed my post to say, "Hamilton68 was a central source on the Russian trolls narrative." which is more
by somenameforme 4y ago
I fully agree; that was poorly written on my part. I've changed my post to say, "Hamilton68 was a central source on the Russian trolls narrative." which is more in the spirit of what I meant. But I'd emphasize that these issues are not isolated. Hamilton 68 was treated as an authoritative source and was promoted by individuals such as Adam Schiff. Schiff was the chair of the House Intelligence Committee which has oversight over the entirety of the US Intelligence Community.
So any investigation carried out by our intelligence community can be well expected to have also taken Hamilton 68 as an authoritative source. It's something akin to the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree. A -> B -> C -> D. But when it turns out that A is invalid, suddenly so is everything else that used it. So that entire article needs to be rewritten from scratch with consideration of the sources and their relationship to data that has been shown to, itself, be genuine disinformation.
One other small thing I'd mention here is that I think the chances of this having only happened or applied to Twitter are very near zero. We simply don't have access to e.g. the FBI Files, or the Facebook files, or the NYTimes files. Which is part of the reason why I said I'm quite looking forward to reading the book about today, in 20 years!
- ceejayoz 4y ago> So any investigation carried out by our intelligence community can be well expected to have also taken Hamilton 68 as an authoritative source. I don't know why you'd assume that if Twitter saw through it immediately (as evidenced by their discussions in that Twitter Files thread).
- somenameforme 4y agoBecause I've read that 'book' [1] for the Iraq War. The evidence for the mobile weapons laboratories was completely fabricated - they were pictures of weather balloon trucks. The 'high level insider' testimony came from a taxi driver who was just randomly making stuff up, and most of the intelligence community knew was just a compulsive liar. Nonetheless, his assertions made their way into no less than 112 governmental reports from January 2000 to September 2001 - and would be used to justify the war. And it just continues on endlessly. Every bit of evidence, no matter how flimsy or obviously false, made its way through the proper channels - so long as it supported the desired narrative. This is not something that can be dismissed as incompetence even if you hold our intelligence community to an abysmal standard. And I see no reason to think that this has changed. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_weapons_laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_weapons_laboratory
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe Bush White House manipulated intelligence to get the result they already wanted. The Trump White House and Senate Republicans definitely didn't want "yep, Russian involvement" to be the conclusion of the 2016 investigations. Very different situation, and a lot more evidence from a lot more venues (including successful criminal convictions).
- somenameforme 4y agoRead the previously linked article [1]. Powell was initially skeptical of the claims being made by the intelligence community. It was ultimately the CIA that worked to convince him that it was legitimate. And things like the war authorization (and subsequent bills) were generally approved with overwhelming bipartisan support. I'm not implying that it was only the CIA, but rather that these sort of situations tend to defy simplistic explanations. It's a lot of different people with a lot of different motivations. And those motivations are often going to drive them to come to the conclusions that they want to come to, exactly as happens in literally every other large organization in existence. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_weapons_laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_weapons_laboratory