4 ms·
As always it comes down to scale not labels. Glyphosate in normal use is vastly more dangerous than anything you mentioned.
by Retric 4y ago
As always it comes down to scale not labels.
Glyphosate in normal use is vastly more dangerous than anything you mentioned.
- tptacek 4y agoIs it?
- hcurtiss 4y agoThat is decidedly untrue.
- pas 4y agoWhat's the current consensus? It's dangerous to the workers who work on the fields, not to the consumers at the end of the chain, or both?
- rstuart4133 4y ago> What's the current consensus? The comments on HN are usually very informative, and this article is no exception. Here we have this comment: > The IARC is the odd one out here and their results are based mainly on discredited experiments on rats that are known to be prone to getting cancer (meaning they aren't a good model for humans in this case). It depends on how you define consensus, I guess. But the data is clear: one organisation out of many, and they drew their conclusions not from humans but from rats prone to cancer. > It's dangerous to the workers who work on the fields, not to the consumers at the end of the chain, or both? I don't know. But one of Glyphosate charms is it breaks down very rapidly. It means it doesn't do damage to surrounding plants that weren't directly exposed (unlike say 75-D). So my wild guess is you would have to be a field worker exposed to it directly. IIRC the people who won law suits against Monsanto were field workers who got regularly drenched in the stuff.
- adrr 4y agoOnly EU considers it a potential carcinogen. Rest world says it safe. No animal model study has shown it to be dangerous.
- Retric 4y agoNot just EU, the World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer classified glyphosate as “probably carcinogenic to humans” back in 2015. Here’s a systemic review showing glyphosate causes cancer in multiple animal studies: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32050978/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32050978/ “The strongest evidence shows that glyphosate causes hemangiosarcomas, kidney tumors and malignant lymphomas in male CD-1 mice, hemangiomas and malignant lymphomas in female CD-1 mice, hemangiomas in female Swiss albino mice, kidney adenomas, liver adenomas, skin keratoacanthomas and skin basal cell tumors in male Sprague-Dawley rats, adrenal cortical carcinomas in female Sprague-Dawley rats and hepatocellular adenomas and skin keratocanthomas in male Wistar rats.”
- coin 4y agoBy Christopher J Portier, the same Christopher Portier that served as a special advisor for IARC while at the same time secretly accepting money from law firms involved in glyphosate litigation. The IARC study was edited to remove evidence to the contrary to its findings. https://www.judicialhellholes.org/2019/05/14/california-courts-drop-science-at-the-door/ https://www.judicialhellholes.org/2019/05/14/california-cour... "Closer scrutiny of the IARC process reveals that it was advised by an “invited specialist,” Christopher Portier, in its work on glyphosate. At the same time Mr. Portier was working for the agency, he was being paid by the Environmental Defense Fund, an anti-pesticide group. Moreover, Mr. Portier received $160,000 from law firms suing over glyphosate. When asked about this potential conflict of interest, Mr. Portier initially claimed to be advising firms on other IARC-related lawsuits and not glyphosate litigation. He later acknowledged that his statement was wrong. It is also worth noting that Mr. Portier had no experience with glyphosate prior to his work on it for IARC. Following Mr. Portier’s arrival at IARC, the final glyphosate study was altered in at least 10 ways to remove or reverse conclusions finding no evidence of carcinogenicity. The agency removed multiple scientists’ conclusions that studies found no link between glyphosate and cancer in lab animals and statistical analyses of studies with negative findings were turned into positive ones. The determination that glyphosate was “probably carcinogenic” was based on “limited evidence” of carcinogenicity in humans and “sufficient evidence” in experimental animals."