You have very, very cheap gas. Suspiciously cheap. Are you sure you're factoring everything in? NIPSCO's rate pages show much higher rates: https://www.nipsco.c

You have very, very cheap gas. Suspiciously cheap. Are you sure you're factoring everything in? NIPSCO's rate pages show much higher rates: https://www.nipsco.com/bills-and-payments/billing-programs/choice https://www.nipsco.com/bills-and-payments/billing-programs/c... In Michigan here, it's like $1/therm (doing the conversion from the Mcf they actually bill in). Multiply your gas numbers by four, divide your electric numbers by three (to reflect a COP of 3 -- that is 300% efficiency -- for a typical heat pump), and your order of magnitude goes away. If your gas really is that cheap, then yeah, you're still much cheaper with gas, but also you've got a sweetheart deal on gas.