5 ms·
> money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services The US food stamp system does this. > unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of person
by pjc50 4y ago
> money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services
The US food stamp system does this.
> unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government
The US police seizure system does this; I submit that if this happens you have a serious rule-of-law problem and already, or are about to, have bigger problems.
> universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat
This implies nonconvertibility?
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoNonconvertibility is a forseeable next step. I imagine first there would be a fee for converting to cash (eg. if you "withdraw" 100 digital pounds, you get 90 paper ones). Then the decreasing popularity of paper pounds would be used as a basis for eliminating them entirely: going forward, paper pounds could be deposited for digital, but not withdrawn. Next, the bank starts applying negative interest rates when they need to "stimulate" asset prices and keep the stock market from crashing. No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year...
- bsdz 4y ago> Next, the bank starts applying negative interest rates when they need to "stimulate" asset prices and keep the stock market from crashing. No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year... Can't they do this already by increasing money supply or QE? Central bank's can already create inflation which isn't dissimilar to negative interest rates.
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoQE is effectively an interest-rate cut but for long-term bonds rather than short term. It would typically be used in conjunction with control of the overnight rate, which still struggles with the zero-lower-bound unless the ability to hold cash is removed from the system.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mywittyname 4y ago> No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year... Why would they do this? There's already a much more streamlined legal mechanism for this: taxes. Plus, this isn't some new feature. If the government orders you assets frozen/seized, then a bank is going to comply with the order. > I imagine first there would be a fee for converting to cash (eg. if you "withdraw" 100 digital pounds, you get 90 paper ones). Again, not new. This is basically an ATM fee. Paper money has costs associated with it, whether that cost is paid explicitly (through fees) or behind the scenes (collecting fees from purchases, selling information about you to third parties, or "borrowing" your deposits to collect interest on it) is pretty much irrelevant. Nothing you're saying is a "new" feature of digital currency.
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoTaxes are generally set in proportion to income, not savings. ATM fees are limited by competition to close to the bank's actual costs, rather than a deliberate policy to eliminate paper currency in circulation; if they charged upwards of 10% on withdrawals, people would very likely leave.
- kwere 4y agowealth taxes exist
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoFor example? More importantly, this wouldn't be a tax on wealth, it would be a tax on savings, meaning it would disproportionately affect the less-wealthy and the less-credit-worthy, who tend to not own significant assets or have the borrowing power to buy them. In terms of the discrepancy with a wealth tax, imagine trying to save money to buy a house, except that the house price grows each year, due to negative interest rates, while your savings account shrinks by the same proportion. Perhaps it doesn't take much imagination, because it's similar to 2020's zero-interest-rate environment, but without the restraint of being bounded by zero.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rkangel 4y ago> The US police seizure system does this; I submit that if this happens you have a serious rule-of-law problem and already, or are about to, have bigger problems. The US police seizure system already is a serious rule-of-law problem due to lack of accountability.
- blitzar 4y ago> The US police seizure system already is a serious rule-of-law problem due to lack of accountability. The US police seizure system already is enshrined in the actual law. However, by the "rule-of-law" it is the law. The problem is that particular law, every single word of it.