3 ms·
The Japanese navy was pretty weak which was the main reason for this sneaky Pearl Harbor attack. In a direct conflict they'd have had no chance and they tried t
by wkat4242 4y ago
The Japanese navy was pretty weak which was the main reason for this sneaky Pearl Harbor attack. In a direct conflict they'd have had no chance and they tried to take out as much of the fleet off the board as they could.
Of course they failed miserably by hitting the legacy battleships and missing the carriers which fit better with modern doctrine.
- chanandler_bong 4y agoTheir biggest miss was not hitting the fuel dumps and repair facilities. Taking out a few ships, even carriers, would be easy to replace. Wiping out the logistics support capability would mean that ships would have to return to the US west coast to refuel/repair. That would have been a major disaster. Pearl Harbor was just an irritant and catalyst.
- credit_guy 4y agoThat's not quite correct. First of all, take a look at the map [1] of Perl Harbor from wikipedia. The oil storage tanks are listed as A, and you'll notice that they formed two different groups. By my count each had 27 tanks. If you take a look at [2], you'll see that these tanks were well separated, with an earth wall between them. It is clear that when they were built precautions were taken to prevent the spread of (accidental of intentional) fire. So, taking out the oil tanks was not as simple as dropping one bomb. You probably needed multiple passes. After the first successful pass, all others had to deal with the smoke, and more or less guess where their targets were. Of course, they would have to deal with the anti-air defenses. The second wave already took quite heavy losses, the third wave was guaranteed to incur much heavier ones. Let's say in the best case scenario, the hypothetical third Japanese wave would have destroyed half of the 54 oil tanks. It would not have made a difference. Only a success rate of 90% would have, maybe. In any case, that third wave was never planned. See [4] (written by one of hte co-authors of Shattered Sword) for convincing evidence that only 2 waves were planned, and Admiral Nagumo carried them as per the plan. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Pearl_Harbor#/media/File:Pearlmap2.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Pearl_Harbor#/media/... [2] https://pearlharbor.org/pearl-harbors-third-strike-what-could-have-been/ https://pearlharbor.org/pearl-harbors-third-strike-what-coul... [3] https://medium.com/war-stories/the-one-key-thing-not-destroyed-at-pearl-harbor-c73b287a719 https://medium.com/war-stories/the-one-key-thing-not-destroy... [4] https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1601&context=nwc-review https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoA small country can't fight an entire continent with abundant resources and free market economy, the rest is just details. Russia is about to find this out the hard way. If Russia had a market economy, maybe different, but then they would have less interest in trying to conquer people they can just trade with.
- marcusverus 4y ago> The Japanese navy was pretty weak which was the main reason for this sneaky Pearl Harbor attack. Weak isn't the right word. The Japanese navy was world class as far back as 1905, when they crushed the Russians at Tsushima. It's true that the Japanese navy wasn't on par with the US Navy, but then the US Navy was more powerful than all other navies combined by the end of the war.
- waste_monk 4y ago>when they crushed the Russians at Tsushima Vaguely related - the Russian journey to Tsushima [1] is quite interesting (in the sense of watching a train wreck occur). It includes the Dogger Bank incident [2] which nearly incited war with Britain. Fascinating stuff. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20220312131211/https://www.hullwebs.co.uk/content/l-20c/disaster/dogger-bank/voyage-of-dammed.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20220312131211/https://www.hullw... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogger_Bank_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogger_Bank_incident
- cafard 4y agoThe Japanese navy did not have industry comparable to the US's behind it, which is why Yamamoto said that it was win in a hurry or lose. However, they entered the war with better tactics and training, vastly better torpedoes, and superior fighter planes.