23 ms·
Who is this mysterious "we"? You don't really need all that much permission to build a receiving station in the US. I bet they just don't want to pay for it.
by ars 15y ago
Who is this mysterious "we"?
You don't really need all that much permission to build a receiving station in the US. I bet they just don't want to pay for it.
To get data from LEO orbit all you need is a small satellite dish.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoGood question, when I wrote that I was thinking "the United States government" which, post Cuban Missile crisis, might seem to be the people who don't necessarily need to approve but must not disapprove of such assets appearing in the western hemisphere. Sort of like the Russians objecting to radar systems in eastern Europe. Generally when I look at the sort of receiving stations [1] that NASA runs they have a number of large steerable dish antennas, presumably a big data pipe from there to the rest of the NASA network. Clearly something that is in the 'footprint' of satellites downlinking to the US includes sensitive military satellites, so one might want to mitigate interception of those signals. So for Phobos-Grunt and others it is more than just 'getting data from LEO' its also being able to "look into" LEO with RADAR perhaps to find out where that dead hunk of metal is that should be sending data, or more likely its pointing its transmitter at an odd angle and you can only get its transmissions when its uncontrolled slow spin points is somewhat 'down'. [1] http://www.gb.nrao.edu/ovlbi/OVLBI.html http://www.gb.nrao.edu/ovlbi/OVLBI.html
- ars 15y agoThose huge steerable dishes are for talking to deep space - like the Voyager probes. For LEO satellites like the one we are talking about you don't need anything like that. Think about the dishes you see for satellite TV - they are tiny. That's all you need - and those talk to GEO, which is much farther. You don't need radar either - the orbit is well known from when it flies over your main base. Radar doesn't have the ability to detect spin and orientation anyway, for that you use a large optical telescope - which again, you don't need permission to use. As for the military satellites, those are routinely cataloged and tracked by amateurs (with optical telescopes), the US doesn't do anything to stop them. It wishes it could, but it can't, so doesn't try.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoOk, fair points all, so do you have a theory why the Russian's tolerate a 'radio shadow' when their orbital gear is over the western hemisphere?