4 ms·
> At this point, wouldn't it be less costly to just learn the native UI frameworks? People seem to be really unwilling to do this, I don't know why. Maybe it's
by pjc50 4y ago
> At this point, wouldn't it be less costly to just learn the native UI frameworks?
People seem to be really unwilling to do this, I don't know why. Maybe it's a language issue. Mind you, the official Microsoft story for how to write a native app is .. messy. But its XAML-based renderers do use the GPU.
- Kukumber 4y agoMicrosoft sticking to XAML is one of their biggest mistake ever WRT native UIs, no wonder it's a dreaded target Then you have both Google and Apple who invested massively into new languages and framework to facilitate the developments of apps and therefore native UIs - Compose for Google in partnership with Jetbrains for Kotlin - SwiftUI with Swift for Apple Flutter in the way to make things cross-platform, all of them declarative, all of them native, all of them doesn't require learning a dedicated markup language
- pjmlp 4y agoThe problem isn't XAML, it is great. The problem are the politics between DevDiv (owns VS and .NET) with WinDev (owns COM, WinRT, C++). WinRT came to be, as WinDev kept redoing Longhorn ideas in COM since Vista reboot, having .NET and C++ as the re-invention of .NET had it been fully based on COM instead of CLR (Ext-VOS original idea). The new Windows 11 widgets started out as COM and C++/WinRT (which uses a primitive ATL like tooling), because only WinDev could come up with the idea of using COM, C++ and XML inline strings, for what Apple and Goole use nice Swift/Kotlin/Java APIs. Only after some backslash did they come up with the C# version of the API. So we have WinDev doing WinUI 3.0/WinAppSDK, porting UWP out of the sanbox into regular Win32 stack, with lesser tooling (.NET Native, C++/CX deprecated, no designer), while DevDiv is focused on MAUI and Blazor (apparently putting into Web widgets is also a good idea). First Microsoft needs to get rid of their internal GUI civil war.
- outworlder 4y ago> People seem to be really unwilling to do this, I don't know why. They are usually _horrible_ to write in. Win32 is an archaic mess. Linux doesn't even _have_ a native UI framework, X and the like don't handle widgets. GTK is the least unpleasant but crafting UIs with it is very tedious. KDE is C++ based and interoperates poorly with anything that's not C++. Wrappers exist but they vary in quality. The Apple equivalent is almost pleasant to work with in comparison even though it has its warts (iOS you can deal with it directly in Objective-C no problem, OSX is more idiosyncratic) And then you have to repeat for all supported platform and rewrite everything. You could use something like wxWidgets, but it's not pleasant to use either. Language bindings are still problematic.
- guhidalg 4y ago> They are usually _horrible_ to write in. No? Basically all the GUI frameworks are horrible to write in, and if you haven't reached a point where you're pulling your hair out then your application just isn't complex enough. There is an unavoidable amount of complexity in writing GUIs and using a cross-platform framework means you get to wade through that unavoidable complexity N+1 times: once for each platform and then once for your framework!
- yread 4y agoYou can still use that 90s visualbasic 6, it still works