3 ms·
I fear we're missing a bigger contextual change in the cost/benefit calculation that these people are making in regards to layoffs. For over a decade it was an
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
I fear we're missing a bigger contextual change in the cost/benefit calculation that these people are making in regards to layoffs.
For over a decade it was an absolute survival related imperative for these companies to hire as many people as possible, and to keep them from going to their competition. Google was so afraid of competition in the ads space that they bought entire companies for hundreds millions, and paid the former employees of these companies huge salaries for years ... just for the purposes of shutting them down -- including my former employer (see Page #39 of https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1563746/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1563746/downl...)
They were willing to let compensation rates skyrocket. To hire like crazy with very little in the way of concrete performance results in terms of shipping more product or increasing revenues. Because they were mortally afraid that someone would compete with them and their ad revenue firehose would stop increasing in pressure each quarter.
So what's changed? Why are they suddenly willing to unleash talent into the market where it can be eaten up by competition?
Isn't Google worried that among the people it lays off (or fails to hire) there's someone who will finally conjure up a company that finally effectively takes marketshare from AdWords or Ad Exchange or whatever?
I don't know the final piece to this puzzle is. Maybe people here have some ideas. (In particular anybody who is still in the ad-tech space who can speak to current trends)
- fullshark 4y agoWhen there's a technological inflection point, there is a tremendous market share opportunity, so hire like crazy to win the market and then once it's solidified, either look for new markets or cut costs. All these VCs are desperately searching for these inflection points (metaverse! Web3! GPT models!) for that reason. These companies all hired like crazy because they thought COVID might have been a cultural inflection point, and when it turned out not to be, they cut costs.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoFair. The thing is they were hiring like crazy and hoovering up talent before COVID, too. Not the same exponential growth rates, but still high, and compensation packages reflected it.
- bentt 4y agoYou make great points about the siphoning of talent. Seems to me there is a tipping point where the benefit of hoarding talent get outweighed by the literal dollar cost of having them. As the stock market drops for macro reasons, this line crossed quickly and they looked at cutting staff as better than keeping them. Then once one big tech corp did a layoff, everyone else took a good look at themselves and did the same. My point is there is no strategy outside of “make line go up”.
- ActorNightly 4y ago>Isn't Google worried that among the people it lays off (or fails to hire) there's someone who will finally conjure up a company that finally effectively takes marketshare from AdWords or Ad Exchange or whatever? From my experience working at FAANG, most of the developers working at these companies are the same skill as anywhere else, they just managed to pass the interview by studying and prepping for it slightly more than the other guy
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYes and no. When I was there I met a lot of very smart people -- much smarter than me-- but they were mostly employed doing really boring work. I look at the academic and work resumes of some of the people I used to work with and they're very impressive. The work they were doing was mostly of the "take proto from here and shove it over there" variety. The really useful people at Google were the SREs. In any case, its beside the point. The distribution of quality of the talent doesn't so much matter as the fact that Google & others wanted to hoard it all.