4 ms·
They've just redefined the meaning of the word "element". It used to be, roughly, a description of the properties of an atom with a specific number of protons a
by dotancohen 4y ago
They've just redefined the meaning of the word "element". It used to be, roughly, a description of the properties of an atom with a specific number of protons and the remaining components (neutrons and electrons) to make it stable - even for short periods (radioactive elements that decay). Now they are using the term to refer to an assembly with muons.
That said, people knowledgeable in the field are apparently accepting this definition. So who am I to say it's wrong? Especially if these assemblies are capable of chemistry.
- mindcrime 4y agoFWIW, that was kind of my first thought. I mean, if it doesn't have a nucleus with at least 1 proton, is it really an atom, and does it really count as an "element"? But I guess that's just semantic quibbling. shrug
- Xorakios 4y agosemantic quibbling is critical in science! I don't care about "who" vs "whom" but I care a lot about "=" vs "--"
- gnulinux 4y ago> Especially if these assemblies are capable of chemistry. As per Wikipedia these exotic atoms have been known for a while but they're extremely long lived (<~in the order of microseconds) so how can we talk about chemistry in such a tiny time scale? Would that be enough time to observe this exotic atom bonding with other mainstream or exotic atoms?
- thehappypm 4y agoMilliseconds is very long for particle physics.
- gnulinux 4y agoRight, that's what I thought, but wouldn't it be very short for chemistry? At least, to make any kind of chemical observation/experiment? Am I wrong? EDIT: Also I think it's "microsecond" as opposed to "millisecond" right?
- dotancohen 4y agoMany chemicals exist for sub-second timeframes as part of a process. Look at photosynthesis for example. You'll commonly see it simplified to `6CO2 + 6H2O → C6H12O6 + 6O2` but actually, there are quite a few intermediary reactions and chemicals produced for short timeframes along the way.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoformer chemist, yeah calling it an element is ok, though I would probably call it something like {0p,1u} H (with the stuff in brackets a superscript). The chemical properties of muonium are likely to be "mostly the same" as hydrogen (for whatever that's worth). Similarly if you had a muon entrained in any other given nucleus, taking the place of a proton.
- gus_massa 4y ago> That said, people knowledgeable in the field are apparently accepting this definition. IIUC this alternative definition is not the mainstream definition. Someone proposed it, and I guess the proposal will be ignored (like many alternative definitions that appear every day). I think the idea of a "new" element is linkbait (but the rest of the video is fine). It's very common to have shorthand like this to use in specialized papers, but it does not mean that it's a new element.