4 ms·
> You are forgetting that the majority of these people did in fact commit fraud. Or better said: The "gastouder kantoren" which told them they could get free mo
by jacquesm 4y ago
> You are forgetting that the majority of these people did in fact commit fraud. Or better said: The "gastouder kantoren" which told them they could get free money from the goverment did in (their name).
That difference is massive and I don't really understand why if you are aware of it you would even try to make the case that the people committed fraud. They were by and large utterly deceived by parties making money hand over fist and the whole reason that situation existed in the first place was because of a bunch of idiotic legislation that made it illegal for people to arrange for their own child minding services in case both parents worked. To the point that even relatives could no longer legally look after the kids without being at risk of all kinds of nastiness. It's a prime example of the dangers of regulatory capture. That a law written for a special case has side effects orders of magnitude larger than the case that it is written for alone should have been a huge red flag for further execution, but instead of stopping they doubled down on it.
The biggest problem here is that there isn't a single individual that has been held responsible for any of this, all of the parties involved hide behind one another or play the equivalent of 'just following orders'.
Nobody deserves to have their life ruined at the hands of the state, even if there is perceived fraud the remedy should never be worse than that which it is supposed to address.
Throwing shade on Pérez is despicable, she deserves a statue for her persistence especially in light of all of the people that went after her and her family, which you are doing as well here.
As for what constitutes fraud or not: I highly doubt it was possible within the rules as set to not be in violation of one or more of the rules so you could write that up to '100% fraud'. Personally I'm really happy that I never had to make use of any of these services.
- jsiepkes 4y ago> because of a bunch of idiotic legislation that made it illegal for people to arrange for their own child minding services in case both parents worked. Illegal to arrange your own child care? That's simply not true. You can bring your child to your parents, friends or whatever person for day care if you want to. If an accident happens the care takers are most likely not liable. And even if they are liable they are covered by their normal liability insurance (92% of people have a liability insurance in the Netherlands [1]). That is of course unless you start charging money for day care (because then it's a business). > The biggest problem here is that there isn't a single individual that has been held responsible for any of this, all of the parties involved hide behind one another or play the equivalent of 'just following orders'. Because everyone is to blame. And they know it and that's why they are not stirring it up. For example hero of the "toeslagenaffaire" Pieter Omtzigt was one of the people who made it possible. He himself was one of the people most vocal after the "Bulgarenfraude" demanding tough laws and crackdowns on such things. And like I said Perez's husband with his "gastouderkantoor" is also to blame. So everyone is happy with this sort of undirected outcry and some reparation payments "resolvement". > They were by and large utterly deceived by parties making money hand over fist Sure, they were deceived with a story they could get free money. But people also have a responsibility themselves to know there is no such thing as free money. You can debate on how hard the government should or should not have cracked down on them. But it's also not as black and white as you are framing it. > Throwing shade on Pérez is despicable, she deserves a statue [...] You yourself state: "They were by and large utterly deceived by parties making money hand over fist" but stating the fact that Perez's husband ran such a company is "throwing shade on Perez and despicable"? Perhaps instead of saying things are "despicable" and people should get "statues" you should argue why you think it's not a relevant fact. [1] https://www.consumentenbond.nl/aansprakelijkheidsverzekering/gebruikstips https://www.consumentenbond.nl/aansprakelijkheidsverzekering... EDIT: I was wrong about personal liability insurance being required. It is required for your car but not for you as a natural person. Added source stating that 92% of the people in the Netherlands have a personal liability insurance.
- EtienneK 4y ago> they are covered by their normal liability insurance which is mandatory for every person in the Netherlands Personal liability insurance is not mandatory in the Netherlands [1]. And stating it as such makes me doubt a lot of your other claims as well. [1] https://www.abnamro.nl/en/personal/insurance/home-insurances/liability-insurance.html https://www.abnamro.nl/en/personal/insurance/home-insurances... (see FAQ - "Why do I need personal liability insurance" at bottom of page)
- jsiepkes 4y agoYou are right! I've edited the comment (and marked it clearly as an edit). Though it should be noted that 92% of the people in the Netherlands have such an insurance [1]. [1] https://www.consumentenbond.nl/aansprakelijkheidsverzekering/gebruikstips https://www.consumentenbond.nl/aansprakelijkheidsverzekering...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dtech 4y ago> a bunch of idiotic legislation that made it illegal for people to arrange for their own child minding services in case both parents worked. This is incorrect. It is only required if you want subsidy.
- brnt 4y agoWhich nearly everyone wants, since the daycare cost for two kids can easily be an average salary.
- jsiepkes 4y ago> since the daycare cost for two kids can easily be an average salary Not if your parents baby-sit your kids. And that's the scenario where this is all about. People were already bringing their kids to their parents and then someone said: "We found a loophole how you can get free money for your baby-sitting parent who aren't getting paid. We'll just pretend they get paid.".
- brnt 4y agoI dont know of anyone having their parents babysit 5 days a week, but OK, you're not supposed to do that for one day either. How does that even work though, you need to provide a document from a registered daycare showing the number of days a week you're buying. Parents obviously can't provide this document.
- lynx23 4y ago> because of a bunch of idiotic legislation Your wording makes it quite clear that you have an agenda. I guess your argument would be more believable if you did not use wording like this, just as a hint for future arguments. Besides, not everything possible is also a good idea, that something modern citizens seem to forget.
- consumer451 4y ago> > because of a bunch of idiotic legislation > Your wording makes it quite clear that you have an agenda. What agenda would this be exactly, anti-idiocy?
- lynx23 4y agoMore like anti-government and pro-foreigner-can-do-whatever-they-want.
- redeeman 4y agoif only there was a way to not even expose yourself to fraud, foreigners OR non-foreigners. If only there was some kind of way we could protect ourselves and society from having our money be stolen by a central body and given out not in accordance with the rules the central body has stated, but is so obviously poor at enforcing properly. I dont quite see how it would work, but imagine if somehow it could be that I as a parent would simply arrange to pay for childcare services myself, instead of having someone steal my money with the threat of being put in prison, and then petition them to pay a childcare service I have identified. I cant quite figure out how it could work myself, as this middleman is obviously performing a service that I would never be able to do myself, but maybe smarter heads than mine could prevail, and come up with a societal structure where I can somehow just go pay my nanny, instead of having someone else do it with money they took from me.
- lynx23 4y agoIf only the world were as simple as it used to be. During my childhood, nobody pays anyone anything for childcare. Lo and behold, my MOTHER did the childcare thing! And the rest was done at school. Interesting past times those are!