3 ms·
It's not that straight-forward, since people with a migration background tend to have lower incomes on average, and are more likely to receive benefits. See e.g
by arp242 4y ago
It's not that straight-forward, since people with a migration background tend to have lower incomes on average, and are more likely to receive benefits. See e.g. [1].
I don't doubt that it is unfairly biased, given that nationality was one of several "risk factors", but it's not entirely clear how unfairly biased it is. That table from the NOS is certainly not the full picture.
It's hard to tell what would have happened without any ethnic profiling. Maybe the group would be smaller, maybe not. Even if we accept the 70% figure at face value (which we shouldn't) and subtract all of those (which we also shouldn't) that still leaves us with ~7,800 ethnic Dutch victims (instead of ~26,000). Realistically, I think "at least 10,000" would be a reasonable conservative estimate. It's less than 26,000, but still a lot and very significant.
The way I see it, it boils down to:
1. There is no ethnic profiling; people still get trapped in a bureaucratic nightmare (possibly fewer than with ethnic profiling).
2. There is ethnic profiling; certain people get investigated more frequently, but people are treated fairly.
Both situations are highly undesirable, but situation 2 seems significantly better.
I agree that ethnic profiling was one of the sins here, but everything considered it wasn't the sin that led to the greatest amount of problems for the victims. I think it's a mistake to focus mainly on this aspect.
> Even now there are people here claiming that 'the bulk of those 30,000 must have done something wrong otherwise why did they end up in the database' and other such gems.
I can't recall ever seeing such comments, although I don't doubt they exist it seems a fringe opinion.
[1]: https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/rammelende-data-analyse-werpt-geen-nieuw-licht-op-discriminatie-door-belastingdienst~b84a0881/ https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/rammelende-data...
- jacquesm 4y ago> It's hard to tell what would have happened without any ethnic profiling. For starters the numbers would be much, much lower and the balance would reflect dutch society instead of this weird make-up. > Even if we accept the 70% figure at face value (which we shouldn't) and subtract all of those (which we also shouldn't) Well, you should: this was fairly extensively reported and if it were wrong I'm pretty sure it would have been seized upon immediately. > that still leaves us with ~7,800 ethnic Dutch victims (instead of ~26,000). There are no figures about the actual fraud but there is a good argument to be made that given the lopsided distribution the actual fraud percentages amongst the various people represented in the register does not reflect reality. If proven this would really put the lie to this system: the profiling not only accused a lot of people wrongly, and caused them immense grief and damage it also caused a lot of manpower to be wasted that should have gone to other cases of actual fraud. The Dutch AP (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens) is pretty clear in their findings: https://www.autoriteitpersoonsgegevens.nl/sites/default/files/atoms/files/onderzoek_belastingdienst_kinderopvangtoeslag.pdf https://www.autoriteitpersoonsgegevens.nl/sites/default/file... > I can't recall ever seeing such comments, although I don't doubt they exist it seems a fringe opinion. Have a look at the comment threads in Dutch media, underneath just about every article you will find these. Definitely not a fringe, unless you count double digits as fringe.
- concordDance 4y ago> For starters the numbers would be much, much lower and the balance would reflect dutch society instead of this weird make-up You seem to have completely ignored the parent's comment about how those immigrants are poorer and thus more likely to receive benefits. This is bad for being convincing.
- arp242 4y ago> The Dutch AP (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens) is pretty clear in their findings The Volkskrant article I posted in my previous comment specifically addresses the figures in that report. The figure are not wrong, it's just more complex when you factor in everything. > Have a look at the comment threads in Dutch media, underneath just about every article you will find these. Definitely not a fringe, unless you count double digits as fringe. I consider those "fringe". I stopped engaging a long time ago as it's boring and pointless; I wrote about this some years ago [1] (the local newspaper being Eindhovens Dagblag): > I stopped engaging on my local newspaper’s website years ago because the same small super-active group kept ranting about “the Muslims” on what felt like every fucking story, even when it had nothing to do immigration or religion. I engaged in good faith at first, but it got very tiresome very fast. For these people, everything seems to be about the Muslims, and there seems little interest to engage in constructive discussion. So at some point I just gave up. I’m almost certainly not the only one. I think you need to be very careful going on random internet comments to see if something is fringe or wide-spread. With a population of ~18 million people even just 0.1% is still ~18,000 people, and if this small group is very active and motivated they can appear a lot larger than they are – even more so if their nonsense drives out people who get tired of them. [1]: https://www.arp242.net/censorship.html https://www.arp242.net/censorship.html