4 ms·
By far the bigger problem is that once you got labelled as "fraudulent" it was nigh-impossible to prove your innocence, no matter what kind of proof you provide
by arp242 4y ago
By far the bigger problem is that once you got labelled as "fraudulent" it was nigh-impossible to prove your innocence, no matter what kind of proof you provided, that people were marked as "fraudulent" over simple banal mistakes or misunderstandings, and that people's benefits were not only stopped, they also had to return all previous benefits, often with a fine added.
All of that was made worse by the reluctance to admit there was a structural problem at all for years. That was the second-biggest problem.
Everything else are also problems, but this is really the root of the problem. It's worth pointing out that people with immigration backgrounds were far from the only victims, unlike your comment suggests (possession of dual nationality was the biggest "risk marker" they used AFAIK, not name, and it's not entirely clear just how biased the results were because people with migration backgrounds are also overrepresented as receivers of benefits).
In short, it would still have been an enormous scandal even without any ethnic profiling. That is not to say that ethnic profiling wasn't a problem, just the lesser one out of several.
> FWIW this is still unresolved, very few people have had any kind of compensation and the government is dragging its heels every step of the way.
This is genuinely a difficult problem. 1,379 people are involved full-time just for the compensation[1] There's even been criticism it's too easy to get compensation, even if you weren't a victim (see e.g. [2]).
Should it be faster? Yes. But it's hard to see how that would be realistically possible. I certainly don't think that the government has been "dragging its heels every step of the way" for the last 2 years.
[1]: https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/binaries/rijksoverheid/documenten/rapporten/2023/02/03/voortgangsrapportage-hersteloperatie-toeslagen-2022-q4/voortgangsrapportage-hersteloperatie-toeslagen-2022-q4.pdf https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/binaries/rijksoverheid/document... page 43
[1]: https://decorrespondent.nl/13592/na-de-toeslagenaffaire-is-nu-de-compensatie-affaire-in-de-maak-en-weer-wil-niemand-het-horen/817712376008-96d24b4b https://decorrespondent.nl/13592/na-de-toeslagenaffaire-is-n...
- jacquesm 4y agoFair enough, it's complex but let's face it: this was just a very nice excuse for a lot of people in government service to go after all those that either have a skin color that isn't perfectly white and/or that came from abroad. Xenophobia at its finest and deeply embedded in the government machinery to the point that it has - to this day - not been eradicated. Even now there are people here claiming that 'the bulk of those 30,000 must have done something wrong otherwise why did they end up in the database' and other such gems. The criticism that it is too easy to get compensation is ridiculous, the compensation has two components, one to level any financial damage done in the past, the other because people were simply the victim of profiling, which the government isn't supposed to engage in to begin with. Ethnic profiling was the problem, the root cause of the problem and continues to be the problem (the whole thing was triggered by the so called 'Bulgarenfraude'), there are also victims without an immigration background but those are by far in the minority and tend to be better represented with regards to the redress process than those that have other non-Dutch backgrounds. Without the ethnic profiling we'd be looking at a small fraction of the number of people affected. https://nos.nl/artikel/2434452-meeste-toeslagenouders-hebben-migratieachtergrond-vaak-met-schulden https://nos.nl/artikel/2434452-meeste-toeslagenouders-hebben... Gives a really good overview in a small and simple table, the discrepancy between the chances of being marked as fraudulent based on ethnic background is off the scale and can not simply be waved away as not being the factor here, 70% of those affected has a migrant background and yet they only make up roughly 1/4th of Dutch society. It would take an extraordinary set of facts to explain this away and no satisfactory explanation has been given to date.
- arp242 4y agoIt's not that straight-forward, since people with a migration background tend to have lower incomes on average, and are more likely to receive benefits. See e.g. [1]. I don't doubt that it is unfairly biased, given that nationality was one of several "risk factors", but it's not entirely clear how unfairly biased it is. That table from the NOS is certainly not the full picture. It's hard to tell what would have happened without any ethnic profiling. Maybe the group would be smaller, maybe not. Even if we accept the 70% figure at face value (which we shouldn't) and subtract all of those (which we also shouldn't) that still leaves us with ~7,800 ethnic Dutch victims (instead of ~26,000). Realistically, I think "at least 10,000" would be a reasonable conservative estimate. It's less than 26,000, but still a lot and very significant. The way I see it, it boils down to: 1. There is no ethnic profiling; people still get trapped in a bureaucratic nightmare (possibly fewer than with ethnic profiling). 2. There is ethnic profiling; certain people get investigated more frequently, but people are treated fairly. Both situations are highly undesirable, but situation 2 seems significantly better. I agree that ethnic profiling was one of the sins here, but everything considered it wasn't the sin that led to the greatest amount of problems for the victims. I think it's a mistake to focus mainly on this aspect. > Even now there are people here claiming that 'the bulk of those 30,000 must have done something wrong otherwise why did they end up in the database' and other such gems. I can't recall ever seeing such comments, although I don't doubt they exist it seems a fringe opinion. [1]: https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/rammelende-data-analyse-werpt-geen-nieuw-licht-op-discriminatie-door-belastingdienst~b84a0881/ https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/rammelende-data...
- jacquesm 4y ago> It's hard to tell what would have happened without any ethnic profiling. For starters the numbers would be much, much lower and the balance would reflect dutch society instead of this weird make-up. > Even if we accept the 70% figure at face value (which we shouldn't) and subtract all of those (which we also shouldn't) Well, you should: this was fairly extensively reported and if it were wrong I'm pretty sure it would have been seized upon immediately. > that still leaves us with ~7,800 ethnic Dutch victims (instead of ~26,000). There are no figures about the actual fraud but there is a good argument to be made that given the lopsided distribution the actual fraud percentages amongst the various people represented in the register does not reflect reality. If proven this would really put the lie to this system: the profiling not only accused a lot of people wrongly, and caused them immense grief and damage it also caused a lot of manpower to be wasted that should have gone to other cases of actual fraud. The Dutch AP (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens) is pretty clear in their findings: https://www.autoriteitpersoonsgegevens.nl/sites/default/files/atoms/files/onderzoek_belastingdienst_kinderopvangtoeslag.pdf https://www.autoriteitpersoonsgegevens.nl/sites/default/file... > I can't recall ever seeing such comments, although I don't doubt they exist it seems a fringe opinion. Have a look at the comment threads in Dutch media, underneath just about every article you will find these. Definitely not a fringe, unless you count double digits as fringe.
- Tijdreiziger 4y ago> people were marked as "fraudulent" over simple banal mistakes or misunderstandings, and that people's benefits were not only stopped, they also had to return all previous benefits, often with a fine added Those who are fortunate enough not to rely on benefits may not realize it, but if you look at the amount of bureaucracy surrounding benefits, it becomes clear that this problem permeates the entire system. If you rely on benefits, you are treated with suspicion by default (by design).
- jacquesm 4y agoExactly. The whole system is rigged against you to the point that people that can avoid the bureaucracy will do so because they are well aware that even the slightest mistake can have huge consequences, and as a result many people that have right to this kind of assistance will forego it. So on paper people have rights and all kinds of assistance, in practice they may well shy away from it because they are too scared, and those tend to be the people that need it most (I'm personally aware of several such cases). The same with 'kinderbijslag', 'zorgtoeslag' and lots of other of these social catchnet essentials. They're made into a massive meatgrinder and one little mistake and you'll be paying back the original assistance + some contrived fine, possibly much higher than the original amount you received.
- throwaway2037 4y agoIn some countries, there are social services (gov't or non-profit) that will assist people to apply for these programmes correctly. Does the same exist in Nederlands for these essential social benefits? My point: A lot of these benefits help children (directly or indirectly), who, in my humble opinion, deserve extra-special treatment, as they do not control their financial circumstances.
- em500 4y agoParent's point are highly exaggerated, see my sibling comment. For children born in the Netherlands to parents with a valid resident permit, there is close to zero administration involved. (I can go into exact details if interested.) It's of course more difficult for the newly immigrated and the undocumented, but that's the case in practically every country in the world and the Netherlands is probably not any worse than other developed countries in that regard.
- avar 4y ago> By far the bigger problem is that once you got labelled as > "fraudulent" it was nigh-impossible to prove your innocence, > no matter what kind of proof you provided I, an immigrant to The Netherlands, had a personal run-in with this system at the height of this scandal. I won't go into all the boring details, but it was basically entirely my own fuck-up. I'd gotten some administrative detail wrong, and was simultaneously in the process of forming a company during that calendar year. I signed up for a corporate hosting/help service that unbeknownst to me (yeah, I should have read the fine print) started directing all my personal tax office mail to themselves, scanning it, and sending me E-Mail notifications about them. I then proceeded to ignore those for more than 6 months (did I mention that it was my fault?), assuming that since the company wouldn't have any "real" operations until late in the year that I could deal with the paperwork then. The result of which was that I got some request for clarification related to the childcare benefit, which by the time I found out about it in mid-December had escalated to a hard deadline the coming January 1st, with re-payments for childcare benefits due in installments the coming February, the first of a few payments being €10k. I'm pretty sure the last of many reminder letters (although I didn't dig it up) had at that point escalated to include some variant of phrases like "in the name of the monarch!" and "pay, or else!". Long story short (and looking back at my E-Mail records) the government went from being convinced that I was engaged in defrauding it of something like the median Dutch yearly income in child care benefits, to being very understanding of my situation, and helping me to file all the correct paperwork. I'm not saying that applied to everyone who got tied up in that bureaucratic meat-grinder, and YMMV, but I for one found the whole process very helpful and understanding. It probably helped that I wasn't engaged in any "real" fraud. The tax office agreed that if I'd submitted the required documentation on time there wouldn't have been any issue. Even though the fault of being tardy with that was entirely my own they were very understanding, I didn't have to pay a penny to the tax office, and they went above & beyond in helping me resolve the issue. I'm sure that if I'd have been engaged in "actual" fraud the consequences would have been very different, but I wanted to chime in with an anecdote-of-one that in my case it was surprisingly easy to go from assumed fraudster to the Dutch tax office bending over backwards to help me, and bend its own rules to help me out.