3 ms·
None of that really counters that there is a conflict, and that legally speaking it's not quite straight-forward. I'm not the judge presiding the case; I don't
by arp242 4y ago
None of that really counters that there is a conflict, and that legally speaking it's not quite straight-forward. I'm not the judge presiding the case; I don't get to decide one way or the other. I'm just saying there is a legitimate unresolved conflict, and that courts are the system we have to resolve that sort off thing.
> If you claim to have lost your dollars you don't get to sue your bank or the fed to replace them for you.
If I claim it's the fault of the bank? Of course you can.
- nullc 4y ago> I'm not the judge presiding the case; The judge decided there wasn't one, it was the appeals court that differed. :) > and that courts are the system we have to resolve that sort off thing. If not for some fortunate historical luck it could only decide this wrongly, since but for some fortuitous turns we'd be forced to lose due to being unable to afford the defense. You can easily replay this situation with different defendants or a different situation and get that outcome. If not for the impossibility of the requested remedy (and the fact that plaintiffs was never to be win)-- I don't see why it wouldn't just be rational for us to collude with the plaintiff and throw the case in exchange for, say, half the windfall. Fortunately for Bitcoin users the system is designed in a way to preclude that possibility, but not so fortunately for us. > If I claim it's the fault of the bank? Of course you can. At no point has the plaintiff alleged that the loss is our fault.