10 ms·
Algorithm is too much of a term to use here. They simply labelled everybody with a foreign (read: Islamic, Polish or Bulgarian) sounding name and/or an immigrat
by jacquesm 4y ago
Algorithm is too much of a term to use here. They simply labelled everybody with a foreign (read: Islamic, Polish or Bulgarian) sounding name and/or an immigration background (including war refugees!) as a potential fraud case in response to some very limited actual fraud that exposed the tax office as being pretty bad at uncovering some (obvious) fraud cases.
Long story short, this article contains some grains of truth but the reality is much simpler: the Dutch tax office systematically engaged in discrimination, persisted in doing so when this was pointed out to them and made extraordinary efforts to hide their failings rather than to fix it.
The most ugly bit: the government that was in charge during all this fell due to the scandal and then was promptly re-elected claiming that they have full mandate to pursue their various un-ethical goals.
Families broke apart over this, children (1100!) got placed out of their parent's homes (because having your parents labelled fraudsters gives extraordinary powers to the government to really mess up your life as if it wasn't enough yet). A number of people committed suicide, one of which was directly traced back to the scandal.
If not for a single lawyer (González Pérez) persisting this whole thing would have never been brought to light. More than the algorithm I would blame the people who willingly implemented all of this. FWIW this is still unresolved, very few people (if any) have had any kind of compensation and the government is dragging its heels every step of the way.
- puffoflogic 4y ago[flagged]
- EdwardDiego 4y agoThank you for the background :)
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's one of the most gruesome pages in (recent) Dutch history and it is far from over.
- arp242 4y agoBy far the bigger problem is that once you got labelled as "fraudulent" it was nigh-impossible to prove your innocence, no matter what kind of proof you provided, that people were marked as "fraudulent" over simple banal mistakes or misunderstandings, and that people's benefits were not only stopped, they also had to return all previous benefits, often with a fine added. All of that was made worse by the reluctance to admit there was a structural problem at all for years. That was the second-biggest problem. Everything else are also problems, but this is really the root of the problem. It's worth pointing out that people with immigration backgrounds were far from the only victims, unlike your comment suggests (possession of dual nationality was the biggest "risk marker" they used AFAIK, not name, and it's not entirely clear just how biased the results were because people with migration backgrounds are also overrepresented as receivers of benefits). In short, it would still have been an enormous scandal even without any ethnic profiling. That is not to say that ethnic profiling wasn't a problem, just the lesser one out of several. > FWIW this is still unresolved, very few people have had any kind of compensation and the government is dragging its heels every step of the way. This is genuinely a difficult problem. 1,379 people are involved full-time just for the compensation[1] There's even been criticism it's too easy to get compensation, even if you weren't a victim (see e.g. [2]). Should it be faster? Yes. But it's hard to see how that would be realistically possible. I certainly don't think that the government has been "dragging its heels every step of the way" for the last 2 years. [1]: https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/binaries/rijksoverheid/documenten/rapporten/2023/02/03/voortgangsrapportage-hersteloperatie-toeslagen-2022-q4/voortgangsrapportage-hersteloperatie-toeslagen-2022-q4.pdf https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/binaries/rijksoverheid/document... page 43 [1]: https://decorrespondent.nl/13592/na-de-toeslagenaffaire-is-nu-de-compensatie-affaire-in-de-maak-en-weer-wil-niemand-het-horen/817712376008-96d24b4b https://decorrespondent.nl/13592/na-de-toeslagenaffaire-is-n...
- jacquesm 4y agoFair enough, it's complex but let's face it: this was just a very nice excuse for a lot of people in government service to go after all those that either have a skin color that isn't perfectly white and/or that came from abroad. Xenophobia at its finest and deeply embedded in the government machinery to the point that it has - to this day - not been eradicated. Even now there are people here claiming that 'the bulk of those 30,000 must have done something wrong otherwise why did they end up in the database' and other such gems. The criticism that it is too easy to get compensation is ridiculous, the compensation has two components, one to level any financial damage done in the past, the other because people were simply the victim of profiling, which the government isn't supposed to engage in to begin with. Ethnic profiling was the problem, the root cause of the problem and continues to be the problem (the whole thing was triggered by the so called 'Bulgarenfraude'), there are also victims without an immigration background but those are by far in the minority and tend to be better represented with regards to the redress process than those that have other non-Dutch backgrounds. Without the ethnic profiling we'd be looking at a small fraction of the number of people affected. https://nos.nl/artikel/2434452-meeste-toeslagenouders-hebben-migratieachtergrond-vaak-met-schulden https://nos.nl/artikel/2434452-meeste-toeslagenouders-hebben... Gives a really good overview in a small and simple table, the discrepancy between the chances of being marked as fraudulent based on ethnic background is off the scale and can not simply be waved away as not being the factor here, 70% of those affected has a migrant background and yet they only make up roughly 1/4th of Dutch society. It would take an extraordinary set of facts to explain this away and no satisfactory explanation has been given to date.
- tehwebguy 4y agoWow, 1100 kidnappings and still re-elected. Bleak!
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, I still find this absolutely unbelievable. And our PM pretty much pretends that it never happened, and that his re-election absolves him of any and all responsibility.
- bboygravity 4y agoOne reason is media consistently referred to the kidnappings as "the scandal" without explaining much of what actually happened to people (especially on evening news). Another reason is that the majority of Dutch culture/society treats the state-sponsored "independent" media as a church of truth. The majority doesn't question them and all the media did (on purpose?) by repeatedly talking about "the scandal" superficially is just make people tired of hearing about it without knowing what it's actually about. I think this lays at the core of why they where re-elected (for the 3rd or 4th time).
- Dalewyn 4y agoEvery time shit like this comes around, I am vindicated in my belief that facts and truths are two seemingly identical but actually very different things.
- 4y ago
- hansvm 4y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 4y agoThis does not follow.
- deafpolygon 4y agoYes, thank you. I read the news here, and it's not all on the algorithm. There was some actual discrimination happening.
- jsiepkes 4y agoYou are forgetting that the majority of these people did in fact commit fraud. Or better said: The "gastouder kantoren" which told them they could get free money from the goverment did in (their name). The fraud revolves around small companies ("gastouder kantoren") thinking they found a loop hole in the law. The short version is they would say: "Hey, do your (grand parents) sometimes baby sit your kids? We'll register them as a 'gastouder' company and now the government will pay for the childcare.". The problem was that these "companies" didn't have things like a proper administration which was required to get the government money. The "gastouder kantoreren" would them make up some fictional administration and get caught. > the reality is much simpler: the Dutch tax office systematically engaged in discrimination, persisted in doing so when this was pointed out to them and made extraordinary efforts to hide their failings rather than to fix it. You are framing this way too simple. The law which mandated them to come down hard on this fraud was written to combat the "Bulgaren fraude" (i.e. the Bulgarian fraud). In which east Europeans (mainly Bulgarians) would come to the Netherlands, claim benefits they weren't entitled to, get paid and then disappear. There was an public uproar and politicians (like Pieter Omtzigt) demanded stricter laws and hard enforcement of those laws to combat this. > persisted in doing so when this was pointed out to them and made extraordinary efforts to hide their failings rather than to fix it. They interpreted the law (which governed their actions) that it required them to come down hard on on fraud. The court initially confirmed (in a ruling) that this was the correct interpenetration of the law. It wasn't until much later that the court reversed on that position. > If not for a single lawyer (González Pérez) persisting this whole thing would have never been brought to light. It's worth mentioning her husband ran such a "gastouder kantoor", which was also investigated. You can look up the court documents online. It was quite clear he was running a fraud because for example all the hour sheets for the "gastouders" were the same.
- jacquesm 4y ago> You are forgetting that the majority of these people did in fact commit fraud. Or better said: The "gastouder kantoren" which told them they could get free money from the goverment did in (their name). That difference is massive and I don't really understand why if you are aware of it you would even try to make the case that the people committed fraud. They were by and large utterly deceived by parties making money hand over fist and the whole reason that situation existed in the first place was because of a bunch of idiotic legislation that made it illegal for people to arrange for their own child minding services in case both parents worked. To the point that even relatives could no longer legally look after the kids without being at risk of all kinds of nastiness. It's a prime example of the dangers of regulatory capture. That a law written for a special case has side effects orders of magnitude larger than the case that it is written for alone should have been a huge red flag for further execution, but instead of stopping they doubled down on it. The biggest problem here is that there isn't a single individual that has been held responsible for any of this, all of the parties involved hide behind one another or play the equivalent of 'just following orders'. Nobody deserves to have their life ruined at the hands of the state, even if there is perceived fraud the remedy should never be worse than that which it is supposed to address. Throwing shade on Pérez is despicable, she deserves a statue for her persistence especially in light of all of the people that went after her and her family, which you are doing as well here. As for what constitutes fraud or not: I highly doubt it was possible within the rules as set to not be in violation of one or more of the rules so you could write that up to '100% fraud'. Personally I'm really happy that I never had to make use of any of these services.
- yread 4y agoI think the government got reelected because that's what people want. Talk to a sufficient number of dutch people outside randstad and you will hear so many times about how the country is full and how there is no Christmas tree when king has a a speech and how there are too many muslims - these people used to constantly talk about how the benefits are being misused and how immigrants are having kids just to receive money and so on. These people are not that concerned about the whole toeslagenaffaire. They might use it to critize the government but the system worked in their eyes.
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, this is a huge factor. Lots of fear of the 'other' here outside of the big cities (and plenty inside them) so going after the refugees and the immigrants is quite popular with a certain demographic.
- concordDance 4y agoIs it rational of them to go after said demographics? Does the existence of such people in the country worsen or improve their lives?
- unglaublich 4y agoActing on demographics based on statistics is called discrimination and it is a crime. Everyone - also members of a demographic that is statistically over-represented in criminal behavior - is innocent, unless proven otherwise, on an individual basis. To put that into perspective: young men are much more likely to commit crimes than any other group. Yet we all agree that we shouldn't discriminate against young men.
- concordDance 4y ago> Yet we all agree that we shouldn't discriminate against young men. This definitely isn't a universal sentiment. > Acting on demographics based on statistics is called discrimination and it is a crime Not if the government does it. E.g. the vast majority of Russians would not be spies, but Ukraine still isn't letting Russians into the country.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoIt’s odd that people ignore the far bigger devil problem that the Dutch public, and most western public, are being plundered and defrauded of their money to support the lifestyles of the ruling class and foreigners against their will. You call it discrimination and I call it theft by the ruling class against its own people to import foreigners that the ruling class can more easily control in order to arrest control away from the native populations that keep insisting on being in control of their own lives. It is sad that people don’t seem to want to understand that “immigration” is a weapon of abuse by the ruling class to attack and shatter the “will of the people”. It has really never dawned on anyone that there is something wrong with the situation when the richest and most powerful people … literal lying, murdering, stealing psychopaths … are all cheering on and support “immigration”, as if anything they support will have any kind of positive impact on regular people? It’s not very sane to believe such lies by abusive psychopaths in the ruling class. The people who start wars, kill millions, and pillage countries … the very same countries they then cheer on “immigration” from … should be trusted on “immigration” any more than they should be trusted??? It is mind boggling to be to what extent people will go to trust their abusers. The same people who are doing this and who are responsible for things like COVID are also the murdering pillagers that destroyed and murdered Iraqis, among all the other death and destruction they reap. Why are people trusting these psychopaths?
- b3lvedere 4y agoMe and my wife were mislabeled as tax fraudsters in this. It was and still is a horrible situation. It is still not resolved. They compensated some, but not all. "a foreign (read: Islamic, Polish or Bulgarian) sounding name" That explains a lot for me, because my last name does sound kind of Polish/Bulgarian and at the same time does not, since my family tree has been of Dutch origin at least from the early 1600s!