4 ms·
> Most banks (by funds/size) use different wire routing numbers These are public information you can find on the bank's website, i.e. that's an inconvenience f
by lxgr 4y ago
> Most banks (by funds/size) use different wire routing numbers
These are public information you can find on the bank's website, i.e. that's an inconvenience for account holders, not a security feature. For my bank, they're also identical.
> and sometimes provide deposit only or different account numbers for wires
If they can do that, they can provide account numbers with ACH pull deactivated just as easily.
It seems like most of the ACH pain points, as well as wire transfer security features like two-party sign-off etc. you describe, revolve around bank policies, not the actual ACH or wire transfer rules.
- lazide 4y agoSince wire transfers don’t allow externally initiated withdrawals (unlike ACH) and wire transfers can be initiated (and accepted) at accounts that cannot accept or initiate ACH transfers, that’s false. But nice trying to move the goalposts!
- lxgr 4y agoWhat are the goal posts? I merely tried to point out that ACH push exists and is practically very similar to wire transfers (in that it's both reasonably final/irreversible, and that an account being set up to receive inbound ACH push/credit payments does not automatically need to honor incoming debit requests).
- lazide 4y agoACH push is not reasonably final or irreversible. It’s trivially reversible, and I gave many examples of when it is actually reversed all the time in practice, which wires cannot be. And I have yet to see an account which can take ACH credits but won’t take ACH debits, as ACH debits are the normal anyway.
- lxgr 4y agoReversing ACH credits is not trivial, no matter how often you claim it! Or can you show me any bank or service provider that offers it as a "trivial" feature (i.e. not something to be used only in case of double bookings or similar)? It‘s also only possible within five days after an incorrect credit, so if you‘re very concerned about that remote possibility, you can always just wait that long before you consider any incoming "untrusted" funds final. And if you think that wires can‘t be reversed you should look into the concept of "hold harmless". The practical difference is that many banks automate ACH reversals, while wires need to be manually sent back. But if you think that you can e.g. just keep funds accidentally or fraudulently transferred to your account simply due to the way in which they are sent, you are mistaken. > And I have yet to see an account which can take ACH credits but won’t take ACH debits Then you just haven‘t looked. Googling for "ACH debit block" yields several business accounts that support this feature, including Chase.
- lazide 4y agoHaha, you’re literally agreeing with me - except for ACH debit block, learn something new every day! I’m done going in circles though. Enjoy!