4 ms·
Well, if there were actually shortages, then wages would increase until the "shortages" disappear. This notion of "shortage" bugs me. There's two sides to a "s
by barrkel 15y ago
Well, if there were actually shortages, then wages would increase until the "shortages" disappear.
This notion of "shortage" bugs me. There's two sides to a "shortage": supply and demand; but they meet at a point determined by price, where both are equal. There is always a "shortage": demand for engineers that isn't fulfilled by supply, because they can't afford to pay the engineers enough. But there is also always a "surplus": too many engineers to warrant high income levels in the 1%, etc.
A shortage would actually exist in a rigid market with inefficiencies, e.g. price fixing. To the degree that's not true, we don't have a shortage.
- potatolicious 15y ago> "Well, if there were actually shortages, then wages would increase until the "shortages" disappear." This is a common thought I see a lot on HN, but it's completely bollocks. The elasticity of salary is not infinitely scalable, and is heavily based on the costs and profitability of the business. Say we took away all the taxi cab drivers in the world, demand would be immense and supply would be next to nil - in your fantasy world cab drivers would start making hojillions. But of course, there is an upper bound to the value of a cab ride - cab fares would rise, but it won't not rise to astronomical levels simply because the cost will start exceeding the utility of the ride itself. So yeah, in a shortage situation developer pay would rise - and rise they have, particularly in hotly-contested areas like the Bay, but this entitled attitude where "there's no shortage! I'm not making a million bucks a year yet!" is complete horseshit.
- barrkel 15y agoCab rides have substitutes: your feet, mass transit, your own car (including the costs of parking), up to being carried around on a litter[1], which would be a very expensive. This limits the "hojillions" available to single cab drivers. If there was 10x the supply of programmers, we could have 10x the number of jobs for them to do: they could be coming around to your house and offering to automate various bits and pieces of your life, they could be hanging around at traffic lights helping people stopped in cars optimize their phone usage, etc. The profitability of the business is in part a function of its costs. That the business exists at all is based on an assumption of a certain level of costs, where at different costs other options may be more viable. What I'm getting at is that there is a circularity in your objection. You assume things about the current state of supply and demand based on the current market mix of businesses, but the current market mix of businesses is the way it is in part because of the current state of supply and demand. Yes, there is certainly a lack of elasticity in salary. The market isn't perfect. People aren't fungible. But the market is efficient enough to value e.g. doctors and lawyers quite highly. It simply doesn't value software engineers in the same way. That's just the way it is; I'm not saying it's right or wrong, and nor am I moaning about my wages (actually, I deliberately choose lower wages in return for more interesting work and flexibility in where I live). What I am moaning about is people talking about an excess of supply or demand, like it's a plain fact. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litter_%28vehicle%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litter_%28vehicle%29
- randomdata 15y agoIn your example, the demand for cabs would decline. People would find other modes of transportation or not travel at all. You are right that an engineer's pay can only go so high. However, when the rate exceeds what you can afford, you simply bow out and do something different. Hire someone who does not have talent or refrain from doing the work. Ferraris exceed what I am willing to pay for an automobile, but you won't hear me complaining that there is a shortage of Ferraris. Instead, I will buy a lesser car (an unskilled worker) and make do, or forego car ownership altogether. A shortage implies that all the money in the world can still not allow you to fulfill your needs. If the fulfillment is out there, but you are not willing to pay the prices, that is not a shortage.
- wisty 15y agoI depends. Increasing wages might mean people work less hours, because they don't need overtime to pay the bills. And you won't see a lot of experienced applicants appear overnight, unless you can tempt retirees or career switchers back. If doctors who realise they can work 9-5, and have lots of holidays, and still have a great standard of living, why should they work longer hours? It does actually happen. Of coures the mainstream economic explanation is that if this was predictable, students will have been driven into courses before the shortage occurred (it's called "rational behavior", or "the assumption that everyone is smarter than an economist").
- gbog 15y agoSomeone above questioned shortage, but nobody seem to question the Want more money part. And here you come up with " a great standard of living, " but really I think people with much less may have a greater life, even if they have no car and no washing machines.
- wisty 15y agoMore money is generally better (up to a saturation point of about $100k a year). But if you are time poor, and cash rich, the choice should be easy. Obviously, some people just like work, and money. Marx was right - people can accumulate cash simply for the sake of accumulating cash (or the security it brings), not just for pure consumption.
- cma 15y agoInnovation has positive externalities (unless it is patented, others can get it for free (roughly)). So, you can still have a major shortage even if supply/demand are meeting in the usual way. (what do you think the reaction to sputnik was about?)
- barrkel 15y agoWell, in a market with perfect information, enough people and organizations would organize to donate money to fund the innovations :) (actually, I think this could be a better model for funding certain types of innovation, e.g. drugs for particular diseases, than patents). Of course, the market doesn't have perfect information, so there is not a 100% certainty on the return on these potential innovations. We must therefore discount them. But they are still valuable; and companies still have R&D departments that do blue-sky research, and we also have government funded R&D. Which you could argue Sputnik and reaction was about. I think these are also market behaviours. So why do you think there is still a shortage, when there is in fact funding for innovation? Do you think the returns would be worth more investment, diverted from other current investments? If so, you should be able to convince enough other people to fund it. If not, does that not prove the weakness of your argument? ;) (I'm arguing this with a hat on. That is, I'm taking a position that's actually somewhat more extreme than my real position, to see how it feels. I'm actually opposed to the market in many cases, but not because of quibbling over supply and demand, but rather because it is amoral - not immoral, amoral - as in it has no moral content. There is no intrinsic fairness in it. It just is, a machine driven by people's consumption, without consideration for whether their tastes are right or wrong.)