3 ms·
I think it's much worst than that. People are becoming "computer illiterate" as the phone has replaced the computer in most people's lives. There will come a t
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
I think it's much worst than that. People are becoming "computer illiterate" as the phone has replaced the computer in most people's lives.
There will come a time when you and me will be the old guys with a milling machine and a metal lathe in our garage wondering why people don't make things anymore.
Or perhaps like the radio Hams. :-(
- chongli 4y agoI've been on a 6-month YouTube deep-dive into electronics videos. I am also now seriously considering studying to become a Ham. This stuff is absolutely fascinating to me. It's too bad hardly anyone feels this way. Makes you wonder what will happen in a few decades. Will there be no one left who knows how to build computers? Will the engineers of the future be using software while having no idea how it works?
- leoedin 4y ago> Will the engineers of the future be using software while having no idea how it works Aren't we already at that point? How many people can fully explain how a modern computer works, from the transistors up?
- D13Fd 4y agoProbably an incredibly small number, depending on how you stringent you want to be. But the same is true for cars, airplanes, microwaves, HVAC equipment, and most complex technologies.
- chongli 4y agoI'm losing interest in modern computers, except as tools. Vintage computers are much more interesting as a hobby because you actually stand a chance of being able to understand how the entire thing works, transistors up. It's also nice that a lot of the schematics and repair manuals are available for these old machines so you fire up an oscilloscope and fix just about anything that might be wrong, unless they use some hard-to-find custom ICs.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoHad a blast with basic assembly, MARIE, etc. Genuinely enjoyed some of it, got to see how the sausage is made, understand from the ground up. Then tried to get into forreal modern X86... and tapped out. Like, whoa.
- coastermug 4y agoHaving a lathe and a milling machine would be my dream. But I suspect the number of tinkerers has always remained constant. Properly understanding computers was always niche. Also, it’s impressive what you can achieve with the right combination of apps. I’m not saying you are, but it’s easy to paint the youth of today as moronic Ipad tappers, but if they can achieve what they want inside such an interface what does it really matter.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI admit the mill+lathe has probably always been a small crowd, but there definitely were a lot more "tinkerers" in the heyday of "Popular Mechanics" (and their entire press: "The Boy Mechanic", "Shop Notes", etc.).
- alexpotato 4y agoFirst they said kids weren't using cursive so they started to drop handwriting classes in school. Now they're saying kids don't know how to type b/c their primary interface is a phone keyboard. Next step is probably Neural Link type connections where we eventually say "people used to user their HANDS to do things??"
- rcme 4y agoWho is “they” and what percentage of the population does this group make up? We should try to do away with arguments that begin with “At least one person believed non-sensical thing X”.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoI think in this case it's a complex intermingling of broad pubic sentiment and governmental policy driven by that sentiment (at some point, school boards had to make the explicit choice to deprioritize cursive and wood shop classes, those decisions tend to be made by groups of local individuals, but in aggregate the sentiment reflects a larger trend in the intellectual priorities of a nation)
- kevinventullo 4y agoAs predicted in Back to the Future 2: "You mean you have to use your hands?" "That's like a baby's toy!"
- alexpotato 4y agoI actually considered mentioning this so glad someone else did!
- Spivak 4y agoIf this is your bar then people have always been computer illiterate and it just looks different now. Using a PC any time after the launch of Windows XP is no different than a phone, the only “knowledge” people acquire are vendor specific trivia and metaphors.
- jrumbut 4y agoI've been working with a recent college graduate, in STEM, who did not know Ctrl-C/Ctrl-V or Ctrl-S because they had essentially never used a desktop/laptop computer. They had one, but it is something like my drill. It gets dusted off once every few years when there's no other option but otherwise sits on the shelf.
- myth_drannon 4y agoThat's very surprising. All through the college they never had to write a paper? You can't write a paper on tablet/cellphone.
- jrumbut 4y agoGoogle Docs on the phone has been very usable for a long time. There really isn't much you can't do on a phone, it's whether or not you can take advantage of the facilities offered by the laptop/desktop.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI would 100% lose my mind trying to write a paper on my phone. I don't want to imagine anyone typing out 20 pages like that.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoThere are plenty of colleges and degrees where nobody in undergrad ever writes a 20 page paper. Hell, I graduated from a well respected university with a non STEM degree a decade ago and still never had to write anything more than a few pages. To be fair, the university had a very strict honor code and the amount of people that would try to plagiarize on longer writing assignments definitely led to pressure for professors to not assign essays as homework. Those were exclusively meant to be handwritten into blue books on exam day.
- nicolaslem 4y agoI am just repeating what I read on HN but it seems to be worse than that: some students arrive in college having absolutely no clue what files and directories are. Their frame of reference is that apps show their data when they open them.
- aweiland 4y agoFor me, while having a lathe and milling machine would be neat (but messy), 3D printing fills that nitch for creating stuff.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoSort of orthogonal to the point that people are leaving off creating in favor of consuming. Even a lot of the 3D printing I see is basically someone "consuming" STL files others made and printing their own gaming figures. Like it's more a way to save money than DIY (or perhaps there are STL figures that fill a niche that corporate Warhammer is not fulfilling?).