3 ms·
I don't think that requiring the original game files is a huge hurdle, unless the game is very esoteric and hard to find. There are many widely-used game engine
by arp242 4y ago
I don't think that requiring the original game files is a huge hurdle, unless the game is very esoteric and hard to find. There are many widely-used game engines that require the game files, such as ScummVM, Rollercoaster tycoon, etc.
The problem is more that many of the open source game engines aren't complete: features are missing, bugs not present in the original, etc.
These sort of projects tend to be pretty large and also fairly binary: either it's complete, useful, and playable, or it's not (yet) complete and it's unplayable and useless. There's a bit of grey area, but a lot less than many other projects. You can get away with "small implementation of X which slowly accrues features over time" with many projects, but a lot less so with reimplementation of games.
- anthk 4y agoEh, you are getting in wrong. There are lots of complete game engine reimplementations with most of the bugs fixed. They run far better than the original game engine on any new OS. If any, it's good to have working WIP projects and reimplementations for games such as Resident Evil so they don't require emulation any more and thus they could run fast as hell on an Atom netbook.
- arp242 4y ago> There are lots of complete game engine reimplementations with most of the bugs fixed. They run far better than the original game engine on any new OS. I never said that's not the case.
- dark-star 4y ago> These sort of projects tend to be pretty large and also fairly binary: either it's complete, useful, and playable, or it's not (yet) complete and it's unplayable and useless. Everything is "binary" if you choose an arbitrary cutoff point. Your example of ScummVM is a bad one: in ScummVM there are games that show nothing but a title screen, games where about half of the game works, games that are completeable but are lacking some aspect (e.g. music/sound effects/animations), games that are perfectly playable and completeable, and even games that have improvements upon the original games. The whole spectrum is present in ScummVM's engines at almost any point in time, as there are new engines constantly being added and others perfected. A game that's completeable but lacks music, for example, is certainly not "useless". The fact that many of these engines are not (yet) complete is certainly not exclusive to game reimplementations. There's hardly any open-source project or game that declares itself "complete"
- lelanthran 4y ago> I don't think that requiring the original game files is a huge hurdle It can be, because unless the game comes with all its own assets, it can't be a friction-free install for the end-users. You can't expect to get the success of OpenTTD if you're unable to put the game on steam, and you cannot put it on steam if it won't run without the original game (which won't be on steam). There other question of successfully cloning a game is "Will we ever be able to replace the requirement of needing the original game's files?" With 2D games the answer is almost always "Yes, we can sooner or later have replacement 2D assets". With 3D games you can forget about it; the effort and skill level is too high for volunteers to make it happen.
- Macha 4y agoThe Steam release of openttd is incredibly late in the life of the project. I don't know how much it affected the users, but it was certainly well known and established before it was on Steam
- kamnet 4y agoOpenTTD was well known and popular for it's genre. Placing it on Steam, GoG and Microsoft Store was more about just making it more accessible and convenient for players to download and update, as users were already providing simple installs for the various Linux distributions, Docker, Flatpack etc.
- account42 4y ago> With 2D games the answer is almost always "Yes, we can sooner or later have replacement 2D assets". This is really not true for most 2D games. For something like OpenTDD where the art is mostly functional and replacting it will still give you about the same experience as TDD, sure. For something like a Point & Click adventure? Nah, the art and scripting is the game, you might as well create a completely new game at that point. The distinction really has nothing to do with 2D vs. 3D.
- bluGill 4y agoThat just means that you need twice the programing effort. Part one is a game play engine, part two is a game content creator engine. Then of course your need to attract people who want to create a game but are not programmers. Of course to create a game of that type needs some programming skills, but the level is - or should be - a lot less than writing the engine. A good game engine with good tools can save users who want to write that type of game a lot of effort. You shouldn't have to write collision detection algorithms to give the user a sword/gun/magic spell.
- Ralfp 4y agoThese sort of projects tend to be pretty large and also fairly binary: either it's complete, useful, and playable, or it's not (yet) complete and it's unplayable and useless. There's a bit of grey area, but a lot less than many other projects. Kinda hard disagree there, I guess. I’m following both Dethrace which is source port of Carmageddon, and OpenGothic2 which is source port of Gothic 2. And both of those projects were massive fun to play before even reaching feature parity. You just need to get your project to the point where game can be completed and there is no crash every 5 minutes.
- arp242 4y ago"Full feature parity" is probably a bit too much, yeah, but to get to a "game can be completed" stage often requires a lot of effort, and it's hard (not impossible, just hard) to attract a community before you get to this stage. Getting to this stage is often the biggest hurdle for these projects, not the lack of free resources.
- AnonCoward42 4y ago> I don't think that requiring the original game files is a huge hurdle, unless the game is very esoteric and hard to find. There are many widely-used game engines that require the game files, such as ScummVM, Rollercoaster tycoon, etc. But then the question is: Why not use the original game with ScummVM, DosBox or a VM (with whatever OS necessary)?
- arp242 4y agoRunning a VM is hard-ish, and in a reimplementation will usually run better on modern systems, may have additional features, support for things like modern resolutions, bugfixes, etc.