4 ms·
I think the jurors would be aware (or at least acceptive) of the notion that describing a picture using words does not create a derived work. That is something
by int_19h 4y ago
I think the jurors would be aware (or at least acceptive) of the notion that describing a picture using words does not create a derived work. That is something a good lawyer could make a show of, even to the point of having an artist draw a picture from such a description.
The vectors are much more opaque because there's no straightforward human equivalent.
- oldgradstudent 4y ago> I think the jurors would be aware (or at least acceptive) of the notion that describing a picture using words does not create a derived work. Describing to a human. Describing it to stable Diffusion is very different. If you ask for a starry night, you get van Gogh's starry night, sometime with the original frame. A prompt can easily trigger it to make a derivative work from something in its training set, and it often does. Any competent expert will tell that to the jury and easily demonstrate it again and again.
- Ensorceled 4y agoMy point is that if there is a prompt that results in a picture that is a nearly identical copy, the average jury member is going to think "yep, that's a copy". Trying to explain how that "isn't really a copy" by explaining AI concepts isn't going to win the day, not when they can SEE the copy.
- int_19h 4y agoIf the textual description in and of itself is already "not a copy", though, the question of whether the image produced from that textual description is a copy shouldn't arise, no? It's not like the jury is ruling on random questions; they're going to give answers to whatever the judge puts in front of them.