4 ms·
It's clearly a derivative work of the original. >On one hand, nothing is stopping me from seeing the copyrighted photo and then recruiting a similar looking mo
by charcircuit 4y ago
It's clearly a derivative work of the original.
>On one hand, nothing is stopping me from seeing the copyrighted photo and then recruiting a similar looking model, setting up a photoshoot in a field with some stuffed crows, etc. I could replicate what the AI is doing. It would be work, but I could do it. The AI is just automating this.
If you trace art by hand that is still copyright infringement. If you paraphrase a passage from a book by hand that is still copyright infringement.
- gamegoblin 4y ago> If you trace art by hand that is still copyright infringement. If you paraphrase a passage from a book by hand that is still copyright infringement. What if I see some fine art, I, a non-artist, make a super-low quality recreation of it with crayons, give that + a verbal description to a different professional artist who has not seen the original, and have them "upscale" my bad drawing into new fine art. Their art would be conceptually very similar to the original. Same layout, same concept, same vibes, same style (if my verbal description was sufficiently good) but all the details would be different. Is this still infringement?
- jcranmer 4y agoIt's a derivative work of a derivative work, so yes, it's still infringement.
- visarga 4y agoIf this worked all artists would be passible for lawsuits, how many ways can you draw flowers in a vase? "They stole my idea, your honour! They used the same number of flowers in a vase, I came up with the concept of 3 flowers first." I think artists and copyright intermediaries would like to have "wildcard" copyright, "draw a flower once, all flowers belong to you now", and it would be very bad for creativity if they got their way.
- XorNot 4y agoThe vast majority of profit most artists are making is also copyright infringement. Custom porn is where the money is, and Rule 34 is likely a huge part of that.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> If you trace art by hand that is still copyright infringement. If you paraphrase a passage from a book by hand that is still copyright infringement. I don't understand how this could work. Are there any examples out there you can cite?
- dahart 4y ago> If you paraphrase a passage from a book by hand that is still copyright infringement. If you have case law examples, it would be useful to cite them, but in general this not true. It can true when the paraphrasing is substantially similar to the original work. It would not be true, for example, if you paraphrase using all different words and a lot less of them. Copyright only protects the fixed tangible expression of the work, not the idea behind it.
- charcircuit 4y ago>Copyright only protects the fixed tangible expression of the work It also protects against people making modifications to these works. When people parphrase something they typically do so by taking the original work, swapping words with synonyms, and shuffling the order.
- dahart 4y agoYeah, that’s true. I think this might hinge on the word ‘paraphrasing’ though. That word generally means summarizing using your own words, not playing mad libs on the original text.