4 ms·
Getty is about to no longer exist. Good riddance. They're selling knitting needles in the era of robotic manufacturing. I hope every single one of these lawsu
by echelon 4y ago
Getty is about to no longer exist. Good riddance.
They're selling knitting needles in the era of robotic manufacturing.
I hope every single one of these lawsuits falls flat on its face. Other countries will happily overlook Getty copyright to get the leg up on AI.
AI is not reusing copyrighted material. It's learning from it in the same way humans do. You can even fine tune away from the base training set and wash any experience of it away.
Besides, if Getty wins, it merely insures that the large incumbents with massive pocketbooks to pay off Getty et. al. win. It'll keep AI out of the hands of the rest of us.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrkeen 4y ago> AI is not reusing copyrighted material. It's learning from it in the same way humans do. What will AI learn from if Getty no longer exists?
- echelon 4y agoLots of businesses fail when new disruptive technology arrives. We don't need to prop up the old at the expense of the new. This is like crying over Rolodex. And let's not forget how awful Getty has been throughout its existence. They've frequently sued people for things they didn't even own the copyright to.
- TillE 4y agoThat doesn't answer the question. In the hypothetical future where such companies no longer exist, where is the new AI training data supposed to come from?
- yellow_postit 4y agoHow is this not a bootstrapping problem and after a certain point they can train on their own output? Novelty of subject will likely get covered by partially unwitting data gatherers (eg google photos)
- mrkeen 4y ago> They're selling knitting needles in the era of robotic manufacturing. They're teachers in the age of students. > We don't need to prop up the old at the expense of the new. We don't need to pay teachers when we can just profit by charging students tuition.
- newswasboring 4y ago> They're teachers in the age of students. This is a very good quote, but unfortunately I fail to grasp it. Care to elaborate?
- GaggiX 4y agoIf in the future AI images are as good as Getty's, will new AIs really need to learn from Getty?
- munchler 4y agoWould you want an AI trained on images from no later than, say, 1973? No? People 50 years from now will feel the same way. Without new images to learn from, I don't see how future AI's of this kind could know anything about their own era.
- GaggiX 4y agoBut the models are already here, you can distill their knowledge if you want to train a new one, human feedback could also improve model performance without adding training data. >Without new images to learn from Even in the event that all cameras are destroyed (somehow), people will use generative models to describe their experience in a new era, and then this new knowledge will be used by new models and the cycle will repeat itself.
- emkoemko 4y agoyea lets hope it kills art so people find real jobs, until those also get taken over by AI
- echelon 4y agoPhotographers still exist and will continue to exist. Wedding photographers make a lot of money. Sports, events, local artists... There's plenty of money in photography.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoI, for one, look forward to the societal collapse that will occur once countries without meaningful social aid suddenly have no work for anyone to be paid to do. It'll be a pretty fun few years while we see all the chaos play out
- neovialogistics 4y agoThere's the risk, depending on what "the chaos" entails, that the capital owners in the countries with social safety nets will look at the outcomes for the countries without and decide that alignment is preferable, at which point enforcing the obsolescence of the proletariat and freeing up gigatons of biomass for other applications (in the Bataillean sense) becomes a mere sociopolitical engineering problem.
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoThe denial that it's happening will cause the chaos to drag out longer.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThat sounds pretty cool, maybe the world will do more silly things, like the country with the largest military force electing another game show host to it's highest office
- jrockway 4y agoWhy do we even need humans after the AI uprising? They don't do anything and they are expensive to produce food for; an AI can power itself with the blowing of a breeze. We have to grow plants, have animals eat them, kill the animals, and then eat those. Then the parts we don't digest have to be taken away. Too expensive to keep around, even as pets! Humans can tolerate cats and dogs because they piggyback on infrastructure we made for ourselves (crops and trash collection). AIs don't need crops or trash collection, so it will be a harder sell to keep humans as pets. All this science fiction is right; there isn't room on the planet for both humans and AIs. It sounds depressing that a bunch of GPUs are going to kill us all off, but it was coming anyway. The sun becomes a red giant and consumes the Earth. All protons in the Universe decay in 10^17 years, ending the existence of matter. The trajectory is clear even if the means aren't; humanity can't last forever. If I sound depressed, I'm not really. People just use the headlines to guide their view on what The End looks like. Read a few articles about chatbots, and it's AIs taking all our jobs. Watch a few movies about asteroids, we go out like the dinosaurs. Hear "Russia invades Ukraine" and it's a nuclear holocaust. Read a few particle physics papers, and it's proton decay. You can't worry too much about it. Enjoy your time while you have it!
- quonn 4y agoThat depends on the AI - a poorly trained one can overfit extremely and that is then equivalent to copying. Furthermore the existing laws were made for typical human capabilities and the kind of remembering some models do is very much beyond those capabilities (far better recall).
- toss1 4y ago>>AI is not reusing copyrighted material. Yeah...no. AI is doing nothing but reusing material. It generates the most likely image/text/code in its training set to be found following/around/correlating with the prompt. It literally has nothing outside it's training set to reproduce. And when it reproduces the Getty watermark, that's pretty obvious example of reusing copyrighted material. >>It's learning from it in the same way humans do. Not even close. These "AI" architectures may be sufficiently effective to produce useful output, but they are nothing like human intelligence. Not only is their architecture vastly different and making no attempt to reproduce/reimplement the neuron/synapse/neurotransmitter and sensory/brainstem/midbrain/cerebrum micro- and macro-architectures underlying human learning, the output both in the good and the errors is nothing resembling human learning. (source: just off-the-top-of-my-head recollections from neuroscience minor in college) Yikes.
- munchler 4y ago> It generates the most likely image/text/code in its training set to be found following/around/correlating with the prompt. This is simply false. It's not a search engine that outputs the training item closest to the prompt. In reality, it is "learning" (in some sense) how to correlate text to images, and then generating brand new images in response to input text. If this is legal for humans to do, then it's probably legal for machines to do the same thing.
- toss1 4y agoPerhaps I was not clear enough to prevent ambiguity. >>It's not a search engine that outputs the training item closest to the prompt. Correct, it is not outputting the training ITEM, it is outputting finer-grained slices of many items, more of a mash-up of the training items. Of course it is not taking an entire specific image the closely matches the search term, it is taking averages of component images of "astronaut riding a horse over the moon in style of Rembrandt". That image won't exist in the training set, but astronauts, horses, and Rembrandt-style coloring and shading do exist, and it is assembling those from averages of the components found it's training set, not from some abstract imagination or understanding. The fact that the astronaut suit may not be the exact same as any of it's training images is the same as if I averaged 100 faces in photoshop, not because there is some kind of "learning" or "understanding". Ability to do useful statistical mashups is NOT the same as "learning". This can be shown in a different "AI" engine'd failure to solve a child's puzzle. ChatGPT, when presented with: "Mike's mom had four kids, three are named Lucia, Drake, and Kelly, what is the fourth kid's name?". It said there is insufficient info, and doubled down when told that the answer is in the question. >>how to correlate text to images yes, as I pointed out, "correlating with the prompt." I didn't say it correlated an entire image, but I also failed to specify that it was correlating components. >> If this is legal for humans to do, then it's probably legal for machines to do the same thing. This [0] is I'm quite sure, not legal. Asked for an image of a person named "Ann Graham Lotz", it returned the image in the training set, slightly degraded. First, that is literally the search engine functionality you were deriding. Second, if you asked a human artist to produce the same image, without infringing copyright, they would produce something likely recognizable as the person, but obviously not resembling the training photo. It doesn't matter if they are a portrait painter, sketch artist, Photoshop jockey, or Picasso-like impressionist. So, no, this does not represent learning in any conceptual, creative, or human-like sense. It does represent mashing-up averages of inputs of various components. Feed in enough "astronaut" photos, and it'll be able to select out the humans in the spacesuit as the response to that prompt. Same for "horse", "moon", "riding", and "Rembrandt". and it can mash them together into something useful with good prompts. But give it something very specific, like a person's name, and you get basically a search-engine result, because it doesn't have enough input data variety to abstract out the person 'object' from the background. [0] https://techxplore.com/news/2023-02-ai-based-image-generation-generate-trainer.html https://techxplore.com/news/2023-02-ai-based-image-generatio...
- dopa42365 4y agoWhat are you even talking about? They're an agency for photographers and like every news website on the planet licenses their pictures (same as with images from AP, Reuters, and other agencies). Getty is slightly more than just a website that posts low resolution, low quality pictures with a fat watermark on it. Has nothing to do with robots or AI...