3 ms·
How does “at fault” really apply here? Shouldn’t these be blameless post mortems that identify what needs to change for everyone to avoid an incident like that
by vlovich123 4y ago
How does “at fault” really apply here? Shouldn’t these be blameless post mortems that identify what needs to change for everyone to avoid an incident like that in the future? Not sure assigning blame to a single crew really helps in moving forward unless there’s a pattern of repeated negligence by some individual or group.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoA blameless postmortem can apply in some circumstances, especially when there are multiple confounding factors but in the case of the JFK runway incursion it really doesn't. There were many confounding factors but they were all sins committed by the UA crew. The UA crew basically got lost on the ground at JFK and drove onto an active runway without clearance and then argued with ATC about it. They were clearly negligent. ATC gave them clear instructions, there was clear and correct signage, they mistook a runway for a taxiway.
- vlovich123 4y ago> The UA crew basically got lost on the ground at JFK > there was clear and correct signage, they mistook a runway for a taxiway. This would contradictory claims to me. I have 0 experience in aviation, but just running a general post mortem, I would say for whatever reason they got lost and the sins of the UA crew don’t matter. Unless the UA crew was doing this deliberately, either JFK signage isn’t actually as clear as you claim or JFK’s runways are so complicated that they need dedicated training. Them arguing with ATC is also strange and I’d like to better understand why the crew thought they needed to do that and resolve that underlying problem. Basically, devoid of malicious intent, what are situational changes earlier that would have prevented the sins from occurring in the first place. For what it’s worth, that’s the way self driving cars are developing. People worry about the trolly problem when I’m fact software just tries really hard to avoid getting into that situation in the first place.
- bastawhiz 4y agoBeing at fault doesn't mean you're being blamed. It would be really stupid to have a postmortem if nobody is indicated as having done something wrong. A pilot may have made an error and been at-fault, but blamelessness means that you focus on preventing the issues that led to them making the error. The point is to acknowledge that humans make errors and to fix the conditions that allowed the human error to take place to begin with. The point is not to avoid identifying who made the error. Of course, gross negligence is still deserving of punishment, especially when lives are at stake.
- ncallaway 4y ago> It would be really stupid to have a postmortem if nobody is indicated as having done something wrong. This sounds wrong to me. If the processes in place allow an incident when everyone is properly following the process, that seems like the most important time for a postmortem, since the existing process clearly is insufficient and must be adjusted.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThe processes in place everywhere always allow for an incident to occur when everyone is properly following the process. The alternative is impossible; you cannot specify any process that prevents the occurrence of incidents.
- bastawhiz 4y agoBut if someone wasn't following the process, and you avoid stating that they made an error for the sake of blamelessness, you're avoiding talking about how the incident occurred. That doesn't mean the process doesn't need fixing.
- Tomte 4y ago"Nobody done wrong" happens in aviation accident investigations. I remember one about a collision between a Bundeswehr fighter jet and a glider over the Black Forest. The detailed report found that both aircraft were where they were allowed to be, the fighter pilot had little chance to see the glider, and it was an unfortunate event. The report ended with "Recommendations: None" (https://www.bfu-web.de/DE/Publikationen/Untersuchungsberichte/1998/Bericht_3X191-1-2.98.pdf?__blob=publicationFile https://www.bfu-web.de/DE/Publikationen/Untersuchungsbericht...)