5 ms·
Note: "tedious, unpleasant task" != "impossible task". Back during the first internet bubble, I was playing around calculating Pi and drew the attention of som
by cperciva 15y ago
Note: "tedious, unpleasant task" != "impossible task".
Back during the first internet bubble, I was playing around calculating Pi and drew the attention of some VCs: "distributed computing" was big. After asking if I was interested in starting a company (I wasn't -- I was going off to Oxford to do my doctorate) one of them asked for my opinion on the technical feasibility of a business plan.
My advice (which I provided for free, being a foolish 19 year old) was "it is provably impossible to solve these problems as stated without transmitting information faster than the speed of light". They funded the company anyway, and $10M later the company died having never produced anything.
Be the guy who says "this is going to be hard, but I'm sure it's possible". Don't be the guy who says "I'm sure I can find a way to circumvent the laws of physics".
- drumdance 15y agoIn the late 90's, I remember talking to a guy at a company that was solving a similar kind of problem. I thought it would be almost impossible to solve and that even if they did solve it the payoff for their potential customers would be relatively small. By the time I talked to this guy they had already raised something like $100 million dollars. When I mentioned that I thought their problem was impossible to solve he said "yeah, that's what we discovered too, so now we're winding down the business." $100 million dollars on something I had doubts about in the first five minutes! And it's not like I'm some kind of computer genius. Anyone with a decent working knowledge of databases and analytics could have seen this.
- waitwhat 15y agoBe the guy who says "this is going to be hard, but I'm sure it's possible". Don't be the guy who says "I'm sure I can find a way to circumvent the laws of physics". Why be either guy? If you know that something really isn't possible, just say so. Hang onto your self-respect and reputation.
- cperciva 15y agoI guess I phrased that poorly. I mean that you should work on problems which are hard but possible, not that you should be dishonest.
- neilk 15y agoThere can be a lot of money in being that guy. I know an entrepreneur who never bothers to check his business plans with even back-of-napkin calculations. He just makes Powerpoints. He is an "idea guy", you see. So far he hasn't crashed and burned because he happened to start his first business during the 90s bubble, at the exact same time that other people were making business plans without doing back-of-napkin calculations. And he sold them a lot of stuff. His other terrible business ideas since then haven't yet returned his net worth to where it should be (zero, or negative) because he'd have to live several lifetimes for that. I think this explains a lot about how mind-bogglingly stupid the world can be. Nassim Taleb wrote a whole book on this theme, "Fooled by Randomness".
- alan-crowe 15y agoRemember Marconi. He wanted to do wireless telegraphy across the Atlantic. Maxwell's equations predicted that radio waves traveled in straight lines. Hertz's experiments had proved the point. Marconi's radio waves were not going to bend round the curvature of the earth. Marconi went ahead anyway. This wasn't stupid. He already knew that radio propagation wasn't strictly line of sight. Nevertheless, radio waves don't follow the curvature of the earth well enough to get messages across the Atlantic. He was gambling that the laws of physics could be circumvented. He won! Not for the reason that he gambled on, but by dumb luck. His radio waves headed off into space and bounced back from the ionosphere. If I were clever I would know the moral of this story. It is either "Sometimes you can circumvent the laws of physics." or its "Watch out for the Marconi trap. He won the 1909 Nobel prize by trying to circumvent the laws of physics and succeeding. And what we have learned in the past hundred years is that people have been throwing their money away trying to repeat this ever since, with no success, so don't go fooling yourself and throw your money away too."